Law popularization live broadcast: I am really not the godfather of criminals!

Chapter 128 People who join in the fun! Even if you die, you will die in vain! !

After Zhang Jingchu heard Zhang Wei's inquiry, he sorted out his thoughts and asked him aloud.

"Lawyer Zhang, the question I want to ask is, if someone wants to commit suicide but causes the death of other people, does that constitute a crime?"

"Or does it constitute negligent homicide, or even intentional killing?"

As soon as Zhang Jingchu said these words, the students around him were not very confused. This situation was very obvious. Even if he was sentenced to negligent homicide, it was impossible to be sentenced to intentional homicide.

After all, during the suicide process, he wanted to die himself, but if other people died due to some other factors, then this was not his subjective idea.

Therefore, even if the other party is convicted of negligent homicide, it is impossible to convict the other party of intentional homicide.

However, regarding this situation, the audience in the live broadcast room also had different opinions on the definition of crime.

"Indeed, judging from this situation! It should not be considered a deliberate killing! However, I am not sure whether it is a negligent killing."

"It shouldn't be included, right? He wanted to kill himself, not kill anyone! How could it be considered negligent homicide? If the man didn't join in the fun, he wouldn't have died, right?"

"Uh... upstairs, what you said is wrong! If he doesn't join in the fun, he won't die! Isn't this pure nonsense! If a person knows about an accident when it happens, what's the point? What an accident!”

"That's right! No matter what! Since that person committed suicide and caused the death of others! Then he must bear 50% of the responsibility! His relatives should give some compensation to the victim's family no matter what!"

"……………………"

While the audience in the live broadcast room was discussing the issue, Zhang Wei thought about it for a few seconds and then said to Zhang Jingchu.

"Classmate Zhang Jingchu, your question is very vague, and the various additional conditions are not sufficient. I cannot give an effective reply to your question."

"If I had to give an answer, it would be manslaughter."

"After all, although he had no intention of killing in his subjective consciousness, his suicide behavior resulted in the death and injury of other people."

"So, there is no problem in giving him a wrongful death penalty."

Hearing this, Zhang Jingchu was stunned for a few seconds and asked with a surprised expression.

"Lawyer Zhang, can this situation still constitute intentional homicide?"

He was just here to join in the fun, and he didn't have any questions that needed to be answered. The question just now was just a temporary thought on his part.

He actually already knew the answer to the question.

However, what he didn't expect was that Zhang Wei actually gave the possibility of another answer, which really surprised him.

However, after Zhang Wei heard Zhang Jingchu's inquiry, he nodded slightly and explained to him.

"Yes, if we add some additional conditions to this problem, then it can indeed be judged as intentional homicide."

Looking at Zhang Jingchu's confused eyes, Zhang Wei didn't show off and just gave an example.

"Suppose Zhang San wants to commit suicide by jumping off a building, and his enemy happens to be passing by downstairs, or someone below keeps asking him to jump, causing Zhang San to become emotional and want to hold them on his back and die together."

"Then, Zhang San has already had the idea of ​​​​killing in his subjective consciousness. Even though he knows that it may cause the death of others, he still jumps and pulls the other person to die together. Then Zhang San is no longer manslaughter. , but it is intentional homicide.” ˆ ˆ ˆ “It’s just that this situation is difficult to define.”

"After all, as long as he didn't say what he was thinking at that time, no one would know whether he was planning to commit suicide or whether he wanted to drag others with him."

Zhang Jingchu was stunned when he heard this.

He didn't expect that such an answer would exist.

It seems that he still thinks of people too kindly, and his thinking is indeed inferior to that of Zhang Wei, a big boss who is used to seeing the darkness of human nature.

However, after hearing Zhang Wei's answer, the audience in the live broadcast room also posted comments in response.

"Damn it! I didn't expect that my life would be in danger if I joined in the fun! I don't dare to watch the fun in the future! If the person who jumps off the building is unhappy and wants to grab someone to back him up, then it's really worse than Dou E It’s still wronged!”

"Lawyer Zhang's advice is indeed correct! When others have extreme ideas, don't join in the fun, let alone verbally abuse and provoke them! If you encounter a ruthless person and want to support him, then that's not the case. Is it because Chunchun hit the muzzle?"

"That's right! If you see this kind of situation in the future! Don't join in the fun! Even if you want to save people, you must make sure that you are absolutely safe! Otherwise, not only will you lose your wife and soldiers, but you will also lose your own life. It’s not impossible to get in!”

"That's right! A few years ago, there was a man here who wanted to commit suicide by jumping into the river! However, the man regretted it and used the person who saved him as a stepping stone to successfully return to the shore! And if the person who saved him was not water-based, Okay, plus the rescue team arrived in time, but he was really killed by the suicidal man!"

"…………"

While the audience in the live broadcast room was aggrieved, Zhang Jingchu gradually came to his senses and said to Zhang Wei with complicated eyes.

"Lawyer Zhang, I am short-sighted and did not expect that such a situation would exist. I was really too careless."

"But, if this really happens, then the family members of the suicide victim should compensate the victim's family, right?"

Zhang Wei heard Zhang Jingchu's inquiry and shook his head slightly with an indifferent expression.

"If this happens, let alone criminal liability, it will be civil liability, and it will have nothing to do with the family members of the person who committed suicide."

Zhang Jingchu felt extremely confused when he heard this, and asked again with surprised eyes.

"Lawyer Zhang, why is this?"

"Even if the family members of the person who committed suicide do not need to bear criminal liability, they should also bear civil liability!"

"If no responsibility is taken, doesn't the person who was smashed to death die in vain?"

Zhang Wei listened to Zhang Jingchu's inquiry, nodded slightly with an indifferent expression, and replied in a calm tone.

"It would be better if he didn't die in vain."

"If the person who committed suicide did not die, then he would not be able to escape any of the responsibilities he should bear."

"However, if the person who committed suicide also died on the spot, then he would not need to bear criminal responsibility."

(End of this chapter)