Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 531 Bloody Battle

In court, Asakura Hiko launched a counterattack by citing the original statement that Mikiko had signed academic achievements.The A4 paper in the hands of this great authority clearly recorded Mikiko's autograph.It records that Mikiko promises that the uncited part of her academic achievements does not include the previously published academic achievements.

The evidence in black and white was displayed in front of everyone.

The counterattack launched by the university once again put the plaintiff in a precarious position.

Will the plaintiff's young male lawyer be able to cope with the counterattack from the big authority?
The people present held their breath unknowingly.From this fierce lawsuit to the present, everyone has long been ashamed of the thrill of the confrontation.Even the university side, which seems to have a sure chance of winning, faced extremely fierce blows from the opponent in several rounds.But now, under the appearance of Asakura Yan, the university side once again resorted to a fierce killing move.

Time passed minute by minute.

Just when everyone thought it was about to end, suddenly the male voice sounded again and said——

"Head referee."

It can be seen that Kitahara was not afraid of the great oppression brought by Asakurahiko, and took a step forward: "The statement of originality of the so-called academic achievement cited by the other party's agent is not correct. The statement of originality is accompanied by the plaintiff Mikiko's Ph.D. The dissertation was submitted together. In other words, the object of the originality statement is the plaintiff Mikiko’s doctoral dissertation. My client’s doctoral dissertation has been examined by the expert group, and there is no academic misconduct.”

"Secondly, even if the so-called statement of originality can be extended to other academic achievements. However, the number of papers published by my client Mikiko during her doctoral study has far exceeded the number of two papers required by the Department of Life Sciences of Kyoto University. And in these papers Among the number of plagiarism disputes, only these two papers have plagiarism disputes, and the rest of the papers have withstood the test. In this regard, the two papers involved in the case should also be excluded from the results of my client’s application for a doctoral degree thesis. That is to say, the two papers involved dissertations are not included in the thesis output of my client's application for a Ph.D."

"Finally, it is the definition of the so-called prior publication of academic achievements." The corners of Beiyuan's mouth curled up slightly, "When arguing whether my client's two papers involved in the case were published academic achievements, the agent of the other party argued that as long as my client If a paper is submitted to an international journal, then the relevant publication is a publicly published academic achievement. From this point of view, although my client Mikiko’s second paper suspected of plagiarism received the publication letter later than the alleged plagiarism The four plagiarized papers. However, Mikiko submitted her second paper earlier than the four suspected plagiarized papers."

"Then, here I am going to ask the defendant's attorney for advice. If you want to define the publication time of Mikiko's problematic papers according to your point of view, then although Mikiko's papers do belong to her published results during her Ph.D., but in this way As a result, the publication time of the papers involved in the project will be later than the publication time of Mikiko's papers. In this way, although there are repetitions, it does not belong to the issue of citing earlier published results that the defendant's attorney just said!"

With the spear of the child, attack the shield of the child!
Citing the views of the defendant's attorney to attack the views of the defendant's attorney.

If it is said that the other party is the top authority in administrative law, then cite his own point of view to attack himself, so as to see whether the previous big authority is more authoritative or the current big authority is more authoritative.

When Asakurahiko originally heard the first two points mentioned by Kitahara, he had quickly planned a counterattack against Kitahara.However, when he heard the third point, Asakurahiko couldn't help but tremble slightly.This third point was beyond his expectation.He didn't expect that the other party's plaintiff's lawyer would actually cite their point of view to attack him.

In a legal case, one party's legal views are contradictory, which is an unprecedented taboo.

But now, such a low-level mistake has occurred on our side!

Asakurahiko's divine sense moved slightly, and he understood the problem in an instant.Yes, they did not prepare well for the trial of the substantive issue of whether the paper constituted plagiarism from the beginning.Because their original plan was to prevent the court from exploring this substantive issue.The ignorance of substantive issues eventually led to the mistake of only looking at the end but not the end when they formulated their legal opinions!
The corners of Bei Yuan's mouth widened further.

Like a naughty bad boy.

He is wantonly teasing adults who don't know what's going on.

The sly smile seemed to show a complacent expression at this moment because he saw the start of the trap.

Yes, this trap was laid early in the previous trial.When he and the defendant argued in the earlier trial whether Mikiko's two papers were public results published during her Ph.D., he had already planted this time bomb.And after a long period of dormancy, finally at this moment, the remote control was pressed to detonate it!

Asakura Hiko frowned, and after only ten seconds of thinking, he immediately replied: "Chief referee, the original purpose of the statement on the originality of degree achievements is to exclude the results that have been published in the dissertation. Indeed, Just now, the plaintiff's attorney proposed a standard to measure the time of public publication. However, if there are two standards when measuring the time of public publication, it is entirely possible to choose one of the two and use the most reasonable method to assess whether the intended purpose of the statement of originality is met."

"According to the plaintiff's attorney's point of view, there will be an extremely absurd result. It is obviously a paper published earlier, but it does not belong to the earlier published results. This obviously absurd reasoning conclusion does not conform to the original intention of the statement of originality , the plaintiff's attorney's explanation is obviously a word game, taken out of context!"

"I'm just making an inference based on your point of view." Beiyuan sneered, "If you say that an inference is obviously absurd, then it can only be said that its premise is obviously absurd, that is to say, your point of view as the premise, There is obvious absurdity!"

Kitahara's point of view collided violently with Asakurahiko's.

It was like stirring up a violent storm in the courtroom.

The people present, to be honest, were already dumbfounded, their mouths were slightly open.Up to now in the court trial, although Mikiko's two papers did overlap in a literal sense, whether it is plagiarism or not, they have wondered why a seemingly simple question is so complicated? !
At this time, the hour hand has pointed to 1:[-].

The trial has been greatly overdue.

The bloody battle between the two sides today has already exhausted the troops.

Judge Kawada sat on the stage.The amount of information in the trial of this case far exceeds that of ordinary cases. The 4-hour court trial brought more information than the 1-day court case he had heard.At this time, Rao, even the judge, could no longer bear the fatigue in his heart.

"This trial ends here first. The time of the next trial will be announced separately." Judge Kawada said, "Adjourn!"

"Crack!"

The sound of the gavel.

The second court session is over.

(End of this chapter)