Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 530 Statement
Bei Yuan's sharp rhetorical question echoed in the court.The author information on the paper does not include the students who participated in the experiment of the paper.Not even their names in the acknowledgments section.These students who have worked hard and sweat, but when the scientific research results are finally published, they disappear like invisible.

The reporters sat in the public gallery, quietly taking notepads and taking notes quickly.Students who participated in scientific research projects did not even appear in the acknowledgments section of the paper.This is definitely another eye-catching news breaking point.Kyoto University, which has always looked extremely tall, unexpectedly has such a situation of using cheap labor.

The complexions of many high-level university officials have become extremely ugly, and their brows are tightly knit.In this lawsuit, they think that winning is almost a certainty, and the most worrying thing is whether they will bring out other things that embarrass the university.And now, this obnoxious plaintiffs attorney is doing just that!
Zhu Ze was choked up by Bei Yuan's rhetorical question, speechless.

It was originally a performance that was going to fight back against the opponent, but abruptly turned into a clown show that contrasted with the opponent.

Takezawa clenched his fist slightly unconsciously.As an experienced lawyer, she already faintly felt the danger of the current situation.If the other party really succeeds in making the judge think that there may be substantive problems with plagiarism in the two papers involved, then this lawsuit will really be at risk.

Takezawa felt cold sweat soaking the back of her shirt.

Since when did this ridiculous lawsuit come to this situation.

Takezawa felt the atmosphere of the courtroom.Although it can be seen from the facial expressions of many people present that they still think that the university has the upper hand in the trial, but she already knows that the danger has arrived.

The plaintiff's lawyer named Beiyuan in front of him, how can he be brought to justice? !
"Don't rush."

A rather indifferent male voice came over.

But it was Asakura Yan.His somewhat frosty eyebrows were still stretched, his eyes still reflected a strong light, and his fingers were gently rubbing the table.The figure and expression of this great authority are still in a very relaxed state.His head was still slightly raised, as if everything in the trial was still under his control.

"Don't be confused by the opponent." Asakurahiko continued, "As long as the opponent loses one point, they will lose everything. No matter how the situation changes, it will ultimately be in our favor."

When Takezawa heard Asakurahiko's words, his anxious expression eased a bit.Yes, no matter what, the advantage is still on your side, and you must not be fooled by the other lawyer.

"Next, let me do it." Asakurahiko's voice sounded.

This great authority will finally end up in person again.

Beiyuan observed every move of the court trial, and seeing Asakurahiko and Takezawa whispering to each other, he knew that the great authority was about to come out again.The person who has been able to suppress the audience with only a few words in the court trial from the beginning to the end will take action again in person.I don't know if it was because of feeling the oppressiveness of the opponent and the danger of hanging by a thread, the corners of Bei Yuan's mouth slightly raised, like a legal monster, smelling the blood on the battlefield again, and he was very excited.

"Chief referee." Asakura Hiko slowly got up.

This scholar, who is not tall, exudes an inexplicable suppressive force between his words.

Asakura Yan said: "The chief referee. The other party claims that because the plaintiff Mikiko participated in the writing of the above-mentioned plagiarized paper, she has the right, or at least to a certain extent, to use this result. However, I would like to remind the court that it needs to pay attention. Yes, even though the plaintiff Mikiko does enjoy the so-called 'right to use' to some extent, but enjoying the 'right to use' and using previously published results without citation are two different issues."

Asakura Yan heavily emphasized the phrase "using previously published results".

"The fundamental issue is not who participated in the plagiarized papers involved in the case." Asakurahiko continued, "The fundamental issue is whether the plaintiff in this case, Mikiko, used the previously published results to comply with the relevant academic norms. That is the key factor that defines the nature of Mikiko's conduct."

"In fact, as long as the previously published results are used without citation, the relevant behavior violates the relevant norms of the academic circle and constitutes academic misconduct. The plaintiff's attorney has just provided evidence to prove that Mikiko participated in the relevant work. However, , these evidences not only cannot prove that the nature of Mei Xizi’s behavior is relatively minor, on the contrary, these evidences also show that the plaintiff Mei Xizi has already known that some of the relevant papers belong to the previously published results. Mei Xizi clearly knows that these parts belong to the research results of past scientific research projects, but Still deliberately not adding citation marks, this can only further prove that the plaintiff Mikiko has the subjective intention to commit plagiarism!"

Asakurahiko's voice became harsher.

The reasoning and theories are intertwined, and the sword is directed at the key point.

I saw this great authority take out a piece of information.This document is a letter of commitment that Mikiko filled out when she applied for a Ph.D.Asakurahiko pointed to a line of text on this A4 paper: "Chief referee. When Mikiko applied for a doctorate, she had already filled in the original statement on the doctoral degree achievement. Article 5 of the statement reads, 'In the thesis Except where noted and acknowledged, research results obtained do not include research results that have been published or written by others, nor do they include materials that I have used to obtain other degrees.'”

"In other words, Mei Xizi has promised that the academic results of her doctoral thesis will not contain published or written research results where they are not cited. Now, Mei Xizi's two papers involved in the case have used the The results published first have violated the statement of originality made by him. Accordingly, the university has a basis for revoking the plaintiff’s degree. The plaintiff’s attorney argues that Mei Xizi has the right to use the relevant chapters of the paper on the grounds that Mei Xizi participated in the work of the plagiarized paper. This defense cannot be supported by existing academic norms."

"Revocation of Mikiko's doctorate is the correct choice of the university!!"

Asakurahiko's courtroom arguments flowed like clouds and flowing water, sweeping over like a storm.It firmly grasped that Mikiko used the previously published results in an irregular manner, and showed the court the original statement of the doctoral degree results that Mikiko had filled out, and pointed out that Mikiko had violated her promise.

Once again the great authority fired a vicious bullet.

The balance tilted again...

(End of this chapter)