Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Above the court, Asakurahiko launched a fierce attack on Kitahara.

The arguments of this great authority exploded on the battlefield like special anti-aircraft guns.Row after row of artillery curtains fell on the sandy ground of the battlefield, splashing the soil like rain.Under the tragic roar, the positions where the artillery screen splashed became no one's land.This great authority once again grasped that the essence of Mikiko's behavior was not an outsourced experiment, but that she contracted others to write the papers, and launched a counterattack.

The eyes of everyone could not help but fall on Bei Yuan again.Although the plaintiff's lawyer pointed out that Biological Xunde Co., Ltd. is in the recommendation list of the Department of Life Sciences of Kyoto University, the Department of Life Sciences has indeed indicated in the list that even if it is a club on the list, it must pay attention to whether there is any fabrication Experimental data, providing essay writing services in violation of regulations, etc.

Beiyuan's expression remained calm, and in the face of overwhelming pressure, he still responded in an orderly manner: "The key to judging whether a paper is ghostwritten or not is whether the core idea of ​​the paper is put forward by the author himself, or whether the experimental outsourcer will solve it together. Proposed. Although the Raman spectrometer irradiation experiment in the paper was outsourced, the reading and analysis of the experimental data, as well as the judgment and analysis of the corresponding protein structure based on the data, were still completed by Mei Xizi himself. The key points of the corresponding paper are still It was proposed by Mikiko herself. Why does the defendant’s attorney keep ignoring the facts and think that my client’s experimental outsourcing is buying a paper writing service?!”

Asakura Yan sneered: "The question is whether the corresponding analysis and data reading need to go through a lot of original intellectual activities. In the relevant materials submitted by Mikiko to the university before, it also includes the information about the outsourcing of Biology Xunde Co., Ltd. Relevant emails and materials related to the reply of the experiment. From these materials, it can be clearly seen that Biology Xunde Co., Ltd. contracted the interpretation and analysis of part of the experimental data. The corresponding data processing has actually been done by Biology Xunde Co., Ltd. be done. Plaintiff Mikiko did not make a major contribution to the work on key arguments!"

Asakurahiko pressed on step by step, refusing to give in.

Kitahara still calmly replied: "The main work of the involved paper is by no means just reading the data of the Raman spectrometer. In the subsection of other papers, the plaintiff Mikiko constructed a calculation method to analyze the structure of the involved protein. model, and used other experiments to determine the parameters of the calculation model. The use of this model plays an indispensable key role in the interpretation of the protein structure. However, considering that the tool for decoding the corresponding protein structure is still the model established in the previous part of the involved paper, the corresponding original work is actually still completed by my party!"

In an instant, Beiyuan launched a counterattack again.

Aiming at the point of ghostwriting, Kitahara refuted Asakurahiko by pointing to the importance of Mikiko's work in the first few sections of the thesis.

"Oh——" Asakurahiko deliberately prolonged his voice, and immediately said in the next second: "Does the plaintiff's agent think that only the entire thesis is ghostwritten? Is it true that partial ghostwriting is just ghostwriting?" Doesn’t it belong to ghostwriting? What the plaintiff’s agent said just now is completely sophistry!”

As soon as the words fell, Kitahara's voice sounded again: "If the idea of ​​the thesis itself was independently produced by me, the plaintiff, Mikiko, then how can the so-called experimental outsourcing is the idea of ​​buying a thesis writing service? There is no model in the first few sections of the thesis. , it is impossible to achieve substantial results in the interpretation of the Raman spectrometer.

"The defendant's attorney has repeatedly emphasized that the so-called experimental outsourcing is essentially the purchase of paper writing services, and then emphasized that my client has the indirect intention of indulging the other party in fabricating experimental data. Then, I would like to ask everyone, Dr. Yu is a graduate student. During this period, my client who has published far more than the graduation requirements, what kind of motivation will she have to commit the so-called academic misconduct? Is it necessary for my client to take risks when she has already met the graduation requirements? Risking your degree to be revoked to commit academic misconduct?!"

In court, Asakurahiko and Kitahara's arguments collided.

You come and go several times, like a knight duel, and the sharp spears make people shudder.

This is the duel between the top practitioners of the law.

Asakurahiko's side argued that the so-called experimental outsourcing essentially constituted the purchase service of thesis writing, while Kitahara's side argued that the original work of the thesis was done by Mikiko, which did not constitute thesis ghostwriting.

Many observers in the back row of the court are already confused.They no longer know whether there is any academic misconduct in the paper involved in the case.On the surface, it seems that the experimental data is false and fabricated, but the relevant behavior was done by the experimental contractor, and it seems unfair to blame the plaintiff, Mikiko.However, it seems uncertain whether the relevant experiment outsourcing is ghostwriting for the purpose of deceiving others.

That's the legal case.

The truth will never be known.

Only those involved in it know.

The outsiders at the moment have fallen into confusion, unable to judge.

"Professor Asakura Yan." Takezawa whispered next to him, "The other party actually has no substantive evidence to refute us. We have the email record submitted by Mikiko before, and the outsourcing experiment recommended by the Department of Life Sciences." Notes from the club, etc., these objective materials are in our favor, and the other party can't quibble."

Asakura Yan looked at the figure of the young man opposite, and frowned slightly, "His purpose is not to prove that there is no plagiarism, but to muddy the water. As long as the university's determination of Mikiko's plagiarism does not seem so certain, He has already achieved more than half of his goal."

"This Beiyuan lawyer really only messes up the situation!" Zhu Ze cursed slightly.However, she was quite helpless.Right now, this seemingly playful lawsuit will go to trial today, but it is far beyond her imagination.She never thought that there would be a lawyer who would do his best for such a lawsuit.This has exceeded her imagination.

"Next, we must completely suppress the plaintiff's demands and completely defeat their attempts." Asakura Yan said in a rather cold tone beside him.

Takezawa nodded.

In the next second, I heard the voice of Judge Kawata saying: "If the two parties have no new evidence and cross-examination opinions, please continue to present evidence on the plaintiff's second paper that is suspected of academic misconduct..."