Grandpa's great writer

Chapter 247
Regarding Affleck's long article, Schubert only replied with this sentence, but then he posted another long article himself, accusing Affleck of some insinuations.

"Some movie stars may think they are scientists because they have played too many sci-fi movies. I was wondering before, would anyone really think that the book "Dune" is a science fiction novel? Now it seems that some people do believe it. pz At best, his tricks can only be said to be logical and self-consistent. He tried to construct a sci-fi system that deceives himself and others within an illusory framework. In essence, what he did was no different from fairy tales. I I once read a fairy tale from China that a man named Hou Yi shot down nine suns with a bow and arrow. I was thinking that it could also be explained with Affleck’s ecological theory. Warrior Yi can shoot down the sun... I'm afraid this is also science fiction."

In fact, what Schubert said is also reasonable, but his reasoning exists on the basis of "the theoretical knowledge in the book is false".

The definition of science fiction is to make reasonable assumptions on the basis of respecting scientific conclusions. It is generally believed that science fiction must have two elements, namely logical self-consistency and scientific elements.

Respect for science is the foundation, as to whether the assumption is reasonable or not is a matter of opinion.

Schubert also accused "Dune" of not respecting scientific conclusions at all. As he said, the ability to predict appeared in the book, which was simply not something that a person who respected scientific conclusions could write.

Seeing that Affleck was defeated, Zhang Chong could only roll up his sleeves and go into battle.

""Dune" is an ecological science fiction novel, and it is also my gift to ecology. If Mr. Schubert read this book seriously, instead of reading three lines, he should be able to see the novel. Some detailed descriptions of the ecological transformation of the planet. Of course, you may have seen it, but you can’t understand the scientific knowledge in it. It was originally a scientist’s job to popularize scientific knowledge with you, but today I am willing to do it for you..."

Zhang Zhong logged into ins for the first time and also posted a long article.

In this long article, of course, it is not just quoting the contents of the book like Affleck. When Zhang Zhong said that he wanted to popularize science knowledge for Schubert, he was really popularizing science knowledge.

What Gaia theory, Liebig's minimum factor law, Zhang re-learned, as if transformed into a scientist.

These things are not difficult for Zhang Zhong, thanks to his understanding of "Dune" and his attention when he was on Earth.

Regarding the predictive ability that Schubert has been talking about, Zhang Zhong also explained.

"The ability to predict is actually an interpretation that combines limited known information. It is both accurate and has errors. These things are written in books. If Mr. Schubert can use a little bit of care, it should not be difficult to see. In your Things that seem fantastic and mysterious can always have an underlying scientific explanation. Mr. Schubert's reluctance to regard Dune as science fiction does not blame you, because your narrow definition of science fiction comes entirely from you A narrow definition of science, and this narrow definition of science is due to shallow knowledge. No one can ask a critic to have such advanced knowledge, and I have always had a tolerant attitude towards critics.”

Your posture is not good enough!
Zhang Zhong's article is very long, but the core point is to scold Schubert for being superficial and ignorant.

Affleck's academic title has already aroused discussions among fans, but now pz has come to act as a scientist again, which makes people dumbfounded.

[After so much, I didn't understand a single word. 】

[I haven't understood yet, pz is calling Schubert an idiot. 】

[The friend upstairs is very good at extracting information. 】

[I'm going, I just checked the theory that pz said, and it turned out to be true. 】

【real?In this way, is this novel really a gift to ecology as pz said? 】

[Is pz a scientist? 】

[Did I actually read an academic report? 】

[Academic reports are not mentioned, but this article has a lot of dry goods. 】

[I haven't read the book yet, pz is this a spoiler? 】

[Spoilers, I didn’t say anything about the plot, it’s at most a reading guide. 】

【Yes, if you read this article before, it will be easier to understand when you read the book. 】

[Boss, what is the Tansley effect in the book, I didn't find it. 】

[This should be created by pz himself, but reading the content in the book, it seems that it should be related to the ecosystem, probably the effect of the ecosystem. 】

[The boss appears upstairs. 】

[I can’t talk about it, but pz said that this book is a gift dedicated to ecology. I don’t think I’m exaggerating. After reading this book, I do know a little more about ecology, and I have a scientific perspective Also opened up a bit. 】

……

boom!
Schubert hammered the table, and the computer on the table trembled, but the annoying words on the screen were still there, looking at him like a mocking face.

Affleck's half-baked article, he can pretend to stand up and say that people lack scientific knowledge, but pz's article is full of dry goods, including some theories mentioned in it. He also checked it just now, and it is true all have.

But Schubert did not admit defeat, he gritted his teeth and posted another article.

This article avoids other things in the novel, and starts to talk about the religious content in the book, and also grasps the ability to predict.

"Ecology still doesn't prove the feasibility of precognition."

When Zhang Zhong saw Schubert's article, he felt that this guy was crazy.

What is Science Fiction?

If it could be shown to work, it would be scientific report, not science fiction.

If Zhang Zhong can prove everything in "Dune", then next year's Nobel Prize in Biology will probably be his, and maybe he can also win a chemistry prize and a physics prize.

This big troll lost his mind, and because of this, Zhang Zhong lost interest in continuing to entangle with him.

In fact, even netizens can't stand such demented remarks.

[Schubert was caught by pz, probably because he saw a lot of scientific theories that pz said, so he had forgotten what he wanted to say. 】

[pz respects science, but Schubert does not respect science fiction. 】

[Ha Ma Pi, from this product, we can see the level of science fiction in the United States. 】

[Don’t, don’t, Schubert doesn’t represent anyone. 】

[That's not what those trolls said just now. 】

[I think I'm going to learn some scientific knowledge, otherwise I won't even be able to read science fiction in the future. 】

[It is right to learn scientific knowledge, but don't learn from Schubert and treat science as science fiction. 】

【He made a fool of himself because he didn't study science. 】

(End of this chapter)