Law popularization live broadcast: I am really not the godfather of criminals!

Chapter 109 Wrong! Big mistake! Analysis full of holes!

"Lawyer Zhang, based on the case you just described, I think Zhang San's illegal and criminal behavior is indirect homicide."

"First of all, it was Zhang San who first made the request for the two of them to go to the wildlife park. I have every reason to suspect that this was his motive for committing the crime."

"According to the express provisions of Article 14 of my country's Criminal Law, anyone who knows that his behavior will have consequences that are harmful to society, and hopes or allows such consequences to happen, thus constituting a crime, is an intentional crime and should be held criminally responsible."

"Subsequently, on the tour bus, Zhang San deliberately quarreled with his wife, prompting his wife to leave the protection of the bus in anger and was bitten to death by a tiger."

"However, since Zhang San knew that the situation at that time was extremely dangerous, he still used words to stimulate his wife, causing her to lose her mind and make a wrong decision.

"In this regard, I have every reason to suspect that this is his method of committing crimes."

"Under such a premise, there is not only sufficient motive, but also very clear means of committing the crime, which is obviously enough to convict Zhang San."

"It's just that in this case, Zhang San did not directly cause fatal injuries to his wife, but caused his wife's death through indirect means. Therefore, Zhang San should be convicted of suspected intentional Murder."

The audience in the live broadcast room listened to Free Flying's analysis and applauded and praised him.

"This analysis and this statement are worthy of a student from the University of Political Science and Law! They are really amazing!"

"Of course! This is our University of Political Science and Law, the monitor of Class A of the junior year, and his academic performance is among the best in the school! If he can't even do this, then we will laugh him to death!"

"Hey! This little brother is actually a monitor-level figure! It's amazing, it's really amazing! However, Lawyer Zhang will not do a business where he shoots himself in the foot! Since he said he is not guilty, then this time Zhang San will definitely not commit any illegal or criminal acts!"

"That's right! Lawyer Zhang is very good at slapping people in the face! All those who wanted to change their lives before were convinced by him! Therefore, I am afraid that Lawyer Zhang will have one more professional law student in his record today!"

"Impossible! Our squad leader will definitely not lose! Since Zhang San killed someone, he must have broken the law!!"

"........."

While the audience in the live broadcast room was arguing and competing with Free Flying students, Zhang Wei, who heard Free Flying's analysis, nodded slightly and responded with a smile.

"Yes, as expected of a student from the University of Political Science and Law. He does have some legal background, but he can come up with a professional rhetoric so quickly."

"However, what I said is indeed beautiful, but you still didn't listen to what I just said. Your perspective on the problem is still too one-sided."

"There are too many problems in your analysis of this case."

As soon as Zhang Wei's words came out, both the dissenting audience in the live broadcast room, Free Soar's classmates, and Free Soar himself all pricked up their ears, wanting to see what kind of problems there were in such a professional analysis.

"First of all, there are obviously big problems with the motive you analyzed at the beginning. You are still looking at the entire case from God's perspective."

"Your teacher must have taught you that no matter what kind of case you analyze, you must think and analyze it from an objective perspective without mixing any personal emotions or subjective will into it."

"Now let us put aside the perspective of God and ignore the premise that cannot be known to outsiders. Just say that Zhang San takes his wife and go to the wild zoo." Do you want to relax, or are you simply curious and want to see wild animals?"

"According to our country's laws, the definition of criminal motivation is the inner cause or ideological activity that stimulates and prompts the criminal to commit a criminal act."

"However, the purpose of crime refers to the criminal's psychological attitude that hopes to achieve certain consequences that are harmful to society by committing criminal acts."

"Under such preconditions and such a clear definition, how could Zhang San taking his wife to the wildlife park be the motive for committing the crime?"

"Also, even if you don't put aside God's perspective and look at the entire story itself, even if you want to define Zhang San's motive, it should be that Zhang San was bullied by his wife and was still humiliated, so he wanted to kill his wife. ah?

"If this cannot be used as the real motive for committing the crime in this case, then the motive you mentioned is undoubtedly even more untenable, isn't it?"

When Free Soaring listened to Zhang Wei's explanation, except for being stunned for a few seconds at first, the audience in the live broadcast room at other times heard the constant rustling of pen tips and paper.

"Lawyer Zhang, you are so awesome! You directly conquered the students from the University of Political Science and Law! This record, if it were anyone else, would be enough to brag about for a year!"

"Hahaha... let alone bragging for a year, if it were left to me, I could brag for the rest of my life! He is indeed an outlaw maniac. This non-criminal way of killing even the students of the University of Political Science and Law must Please humbly ask for advice!”

"Suddenly, I felt like I was seeing the class teacher helping students with their homework! I haven't experienced this feeling for decades!"

"Hey, where are the people who made the argument just now? Don't they call themselves students from the University of Political Science and Law? Several people came out and continued to refute us! Hehehehe..."

"Those students, probably just like me, are busy taking notes right now! Hahaha..."

"…………"

Under the ridicule of many netizens in the live broadcast room, the fierce collision between the free-flying pen tip and the paper came to an end briefly.

"Lawyer Zhang, now that the motive issue has been revised, can we convict Zhang San?"

Faced with Free Soar's inquiry, Zhang Wei shook his head slightly and continued to explain patiently.

"This is far from enough. You still have many logical errors on this issue."

"You just said that Zhang San's method of committing the crime was to deliberately anger the victim, causing the victim to become overly emotional, thus falling into an environment with fatal dangers."

"Actually, your understanding is completely wrong."

"First of all, we need to know one thing. The quarrel between Zhang San and his wife was just an emotional dispute between two people."

"Even though this situation led to the death of Zhang San's wife, it seems that there is a certain causal relationship between the two, but in fact, Zhang San had no motive for committing the crime in this situation."

(End of this chapter)