If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 97 Please ask the judge to avoid it

"Still investigating."

Looking at the messages on his phone, Ren Zhen sighed.

Since there is not much progress yet, we can only work hard elsewhere.

If nothing else goes wrong, Shi Hao's side can be stabilized for the time being, and he will have to take some action on his side.

Others are bullying you at home, so you can’t just do nothing, right?
That makes me a bit useless as a lawyer.

Who says lawyers can only play a role in court?

Turn on the computer and slide the mouse slowly.

Finally settled on a certain user interface.

Click on the private message and type a few words: "Hello, I am Ren Zhen."

G City Intermediate Court.

"Brother Hao, I'll wait for you outside."

Chang Jiahang handed the folder to Shi Hao and stopped at the door.

"What, you really don't want to go in?"

Holding the folder in his arms, Shi Hao was obviously a little nervous.

"What you said is as if you are inviting me to your house for tea."

Chang Jiahang couldn't laugh or cry: "Ren Lu is not here, and trainee lawyers cannot appear in court alone. You can only go in by yourself."

"I know, I'm just being polite."

Shi Hao was obviously so nervous that he lost consciousness.

"It's okay, everything is written down, just read it according to it."

Chang Jiahang reassured him: "If nothing else happens, we will meet again soon."

"Don't plant the flag. You don't usually see people saying this in movies."

Shi Hao burst into tears.

"Bah bah bah!"

Chang Jiahang said angrily: "I said fast, within an hour!
Are you going to court instead of a battlefield? Do you really think of yourself as the leading actor? "

With Chang Jiahang's encouragement like sending a child to kindergarten on the first day, Shi Hao finally entered the court on his own.

9: 15.

Di Ming and Cheng Liang pushed the door open and came in.

Immediately afterwards, the clerk came to the court with two people.

Seeing the person behind the clerk, Shi Hao's pupils shrank suddenly.

"Mr. Shi, long time no see."

Duan Fang smiled, walked a few steps this way, and stretched out his hand to Shi Hao.

If he were not in court, he would have thought he was greeting a friend.

Shi Hao ignored him, just glared at him coldly, and then turned his head to the side.

It was Duan Fang who was responsible for communicating with him at Youen Company back then.

It was under Duan Fang's constant temptation that Shi Hao gradually walked into the trap of Youen Company and ended up where he is today.

Seeing that Shi Hao had no intention of shaking hands, Duan Fang was not embarrassed, laughed and stopped talking.

The moment he turned around, Duan Fang's eyes turned extremely cold.

Are you still going to stop calming down after being released from prison?Then I will play with you today!
You have caused us no peace, and I will tell you not to have an easy time in the future!
9: 30.

The three judges appeared on time at the trial bench.

“The Xincheng District People’s Court of G City, Province C, heard the case in which the Xincheng District Public Prosecution Court of G City accused the defendant Shi Hao of committing the crime of extortion, and made a judgment (20XX) Xin Xing Chu Zi No. 20 on X, Year X, 231XX.

After reviewing the protest application of the G City Public Prosecution Court, this court decided to conduct a retrial, and the first hearing was held on X day, 20XX.

Since some facts are still unclear, this court held a second hearing today.

In order to clarify the facts of the case and make a fair and reasonable judgment in accordance with the law, Duan Fang and Guo Jianshuang, the heads of Youen Company, were invited to appear in court at this hearing to help understand the situation and clarify the facts of the case.

Except for Youen Company, the people who appeared in court this time were completely the same as those in the previous trial. "

Duan Fang sat there, looking calm and composed.

understand situation?

I know all too well!

I can't wait to see the stunned expression on Shi Hao's face.

Come on, come on, let's get started!

"Did Shi Hao, the defendant in the original trial, apply to recuse himself from the relevant persons in the court?"

After asking this question, Liu Lin had already looked at his notebook.

Before the trial, he had clearly written down the basic arrangements for the trial, and then he only needed to make appropriate adjustments based on the speeches of the relevant people.

"Application for recusal."

Shi Hao tried to make his voice sound calmer.

At the prosecutor's seat, Di Ming raised his head in surprise.

Duan Fang and his followers didn't react at all. They just felt that these four words didn't seem right, but what exactly was wrong?
I don’t litigate all day long, how would I know?

"Okay, since you have no objections, huh?"

Liu Lin was stunned: "What did you say? Do you want to apply for recusal?"

"Yes, I apply for recusal." Shi Hao nodded.

“Defendant in the original trial, I want to remind you that the person in charge of Youen Company is here today to help clarify the facts that we did not find out in the last trial.

They are here today as witnesses. If you apply for their recusal, many evidences and facts may not be able to be determined. "

Liu Lin actually wanted to say that there was no point in asking them to avoid it, and it was even detrimental to him.

However, the judge's position prevented him from saying such clear-cut words and could only give a vague reminder.

"I'm not shying away from applying to Unicom."

Only then did Shi Hao realize that because he was too nervous, he had not made it clear who he was applying for avoidance:
"I am applying for the judge's recusal."

"The judge recused himself?"

Not only Liu Lin, but also Duan Fang was confused.

What kind of way is this?
No one expected that Shi Hao would make such a request.

"Who is being avoided?"

Although he was full of doubts, Liu Lin continued to ask.

"you."

Shi Hao answered somewhat cautiously.

"I?"

The two judges Fang Ting and Li Yilu next to them looked at each other and breathed a sigh of relief.

Although being applied for recusal will not have any substantial impact, in their line of work, every time you are applied for recusal, you have to worry about whether you are inadvertently involved with someone inexplicably.

Although I claim to have a clear conscience, I am afraid that my unintentional actions will be taken advantage of by people with intentional intentions.

Now that I am not the one being applied for, I feel a little more relaxed subconsciously.

"What is your reason for applying for my recusal?"

Shi Hao had already taken out everything in the folder and pulled out a piece of paper.

"This Judge Liu seems to have participated in the review of my retrial application?"

After reading the contents on the paper again and confirming that it was correct, Shi Hao slowly spoke.

"what?"

Liu Lin was dumbfounded.

"Old Liu, have you participated?"

Fang Ting and Li Yilu were both confused.

According to the relevant provisions of the Supreme Law on the trial procedures of criminal retrial cases, if a judge has participated in the review procedure of a retrial case, he cannot participate in subsequent trials.

But when the retrial decision was issued, Liu Lin didn't seem to be among the people responsible for the review, right?

"If the judge needs it, I have a written recusal request."

Shi Hao raised the A4 paper in his hand very considerately.

The clerk checked with several judges in the trial court and took the paper from Shi Hao's hand.

Fang Ting and Li Yilu went over to take a look, then turned to look at Liu Lin.

"Old Liu?"

Liu Lin's expression was not very good: "In this case, the parties involved submitted an application for retrial to our court, and then applied again to the Public Prosecution Court.

On our side, we rejected their application for retrial. For the current retrial, we started the retrial process only after the Public Prosecution Court filed a protest. "

The two judges were stunned.

Although the result is the same, the retrial procedure is initiated, there are two processes.

The first is that the court directly decides on a retrial after reviewing the party’s application for retrial.

The second is for the parties to submit a retrial application to the Public Prosecution Court. After the Public Prosecution Court reviews it, they file a protest. The court then reviews the Public Prosecution Court's protest and decides whether to initiate a retrial.

This case is obviously the second case.

Liu Lin did not participate in the review of the protest by the Public Prosecution Court, so his name was not included in the retrial decision, which was in compliance with procedural regulations.

But there is a special situation in this case. Before the Public Prosecution Court filed a protest, Shi Hao also submitted a retrial application to the G City Intermediate Court, but it was ultimately rejected.

Liu Lin was the judge directly responsible for this matter at that time.

The three judges were speechless.

They knew that the president asked Liu Lin to participate in this case because he was familiar with the case.

Moreover, this case was ultimately handled by the Public Prosecution Court, and Liu Lin did not participate. As a member of the collegial panel, on the surface, there should be no problems.

But now that the parties involved have raised it, although the final retrial came from the Public Prosecution Court first, you, Judge Liu, participated in the review of my case.

Even if you reject it, just say whether you participated in it, right?

That's true.

The three judges were a little unsure at the same time.

Therefore, if I participated in the court’s review of the retrial application but did not participate in the review of the Public Prosecution Court’s protest, is this a stipulated situation?

Even though the three of them together are over 100 years old and have experienced a lot, they are still confused at the same time.

It seems like this is the first time we have encountered this situation?
After all, there are not many retrial cases. The court first rejects the retrial application, and the Public Prosecution Court continues to file even fewer protests.

What a coincidence, such a special situation caught them up.

Maybe this situation has never happened in the entire G City Intermediate Court.

So what to do?
The three judges looked at me and I looked at you, falling into an awkward situation of staring at each other.

(End of this chapter)