If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 86 Heart Evidence
"Although the prosecutor said that Shi Hao's behavior should not be simply recognized as civil compensation, based on the existing evidence, it cannot be determined that Shi Hao's behavior meets the constituent elements of extortion.

According to the principle of acquittal, Shi Hao should also be found innocent.

Please ask the court to find out the facts, rule according to law, and restore innocence and justice to the defendant! "

Having said this, it means that Ren Zhen has nothing more to add.

Finally breathing a sigh of relief, Liu Lin stretched slightly:
"Prosecutor, do you have anything else to say about the defender's opinion?"

"No more, Judge."

Zhai Ming shook his head: "But in this case, some facts are still not clear enough, especially the part involving Youen Company. The prosecutor believes that it should be clarified."

The prosecutor stopped talking. Liu Lin looked here and there, knowing that the trial was over.

Seeing the three judges getting together and biting their ears again, Ren Zhen opened the thermos cup and loosened the string slightly.

Ren Zhen didn't have any objections to Zhai Ming's suggestion to clarify the facts.

Although throughout the entire trial, it seemed that their side had the upper hand, but it only seemed like it.

Although some of the facts found in the original trial and the trial thinking of the original trial were reasonably questioned by him, it did not mean that Shi Hao was definitely not guilty.

Again, what’s on paper is important, but it’s not everything.

Judges are also human beings, and they may make omissions or oversights. That’s why the prosecutor needs to bring charges, and that’s why lawyers need to put forward targeted defenses.

Otherwise, wouldn’t it be enough for the judge to just look at the evidence and make a ruling?

So before today's trial, Shi Hao might still be guilty before the judge.

But now, after Ren Zhen's excavation of evidence and re-elaboration of the facts, Shi Hao's crime has become a question mark in the judge's mind.

But this also just shows that the facts determined by the judge are not objective facts.

If Ren Zhen can change the judge's judgment, it means that there is a possibility that the judge's judgment will change again.

Zhai Ming suggested to make it more clear, that is, to implement the final possibility.

As for whether to make a cross or a check in the end, it depends on what the facts look like in the judge's mind after it is clear.

So after many people file a lawsuit, they always feel that things are clearly what I said. Why doesn’t the judge believe me?
Because your evidence is very likely not enough to prove the facts you said, and you don't know it.

Therefore, some people always think that I am fully prepared, regardless of whether I find a lawyer or not.

But the results are often not as expected.

Because the same evidence, through different presentation methods and elaboration ideas, has different importance in the mind of the judge.

While Ren Zhen was thinking about the so-called "heart evidence", the discussion in the trial seat was in full swing.

"At present, it seems hard to say whether Shi Hao is guilty or not, but the first-instance verdict will definitely be changed."

Liu Lin glanced at the auditorium, and it was obvious that some people were starting to feel restless.

"Well, the few things that are unclear are basically related to Youen."

Fang Ting agreed: "For example, as mentioned today, the first phone call between Shi Hao and You En was on June 20, 6XX. Although this is already clear, was there any other way before the phone call? Have you ever contacted or hinted at it? Whenever there is such a time, it will directly affect the determination of Shi Hao's criminal intent."

"There is also the specific situation of the negotiations on the 29th. What exactly they talked about. The evidence now only has a claim."

Li Yilu continued: "If this was an ordinary blackmail, the evidence would be enough, but from the current situation, it seems that it is most likely initiated by Youen, so more evidence is needed. Now it is just Shi Hao's opinion. If you want to determine whether the 200 million is a legitimate rights protection, you must clarify who first proposed the 200 million and under what premise. This will directly lead to different s consequence.

We are still not sure about these aspects. We must make sure that what Youen and Shihao said are consistent, so that the trial can continue to move forward. "

Seeing that Fang Ting and Li Yilu had the same opinions as himself, Liu Lin breathed a sigh of relief.

If they don't all agree internally, it will be even more difficult.

“Basically, there is no suspense about changing the sentence, but we have to be more cautious about how to sentence it specifically.

That's it, let's contact Youen Company and let's hold another court hearing after we understand it. "

In the end, Liu Lin made the decision, and the other two nodded silently.

They didn't need Liu Lin to tell them that no matter what the outcome of this case was, it would cause an uproar.

If Shi Hao is finally confirmed not guilty, then this matter will become a big deal.

If Shi Hao is not guilty, Youen Company, as the reporter, will definitely give an explanation.

And according to the logic of the defense lawyer at the trial today, this possibility is really not small.

Companies with faulty products get away with it, while innocent people go to jail.

Where is the dignity of the law?
Just thinking about it should make some people sweat.

Although the direct responsibility lies with the court of first instance, as colleagues in the same system, this situation is obviously not what Liu Lin and others want to see.

But looking at it on the other hand, it would be okay if Shi Hao was still guilty. That means there was something wrong with the first and second instance courts' determination of the facts, and it could be considered a negligence at best.

If the process is wrong and the result is right, then things will come back full circle.

Although it will also cause some criticism, compared with the previous result, this is undoubtedly the best situation.

Of course, it is for the first and second instance courts.

The judges did not deliberate for long, and soon they all sat back in their seats.

Shi Hao immediately cheered up, and Di Ming, who was opposite him, straightened his back again.

Ren Zhen took a sip of hot water and looked calm.

"Ren Lu, aren't you nervous?"

Chang Jiahang asked softly.

Although he was also an entrusted litigation agent and did a lot of auxiliary work before the trial, he was just a facade during the trial.

Even so, his nervousness was not much better than Shi Hao's.

As the main C of his side, Ren Zhen was too calm when the results were announced.

"What are you nervous about?"

Seeing that this stupid young man couldn't even see this, Ren Zhen looked like he hated iron and steel:
"This case cannot be settled today."

(End of this chapter)