If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 8 I have objections!

When we arrived at the court, the prosecutor was already there.

Ren Zhen took out a thick pile of information from his bag and spread it out on the table.

Take a deep breath and wait for the trial to begin.

Not long after, Wen Xuan walked into the dock under the leadership of the bailiff.

Clerk Wang Shiyang, whom he had met before, began to read out the court discipline.

"In order to maintain order in the court and ensure the smooth progress of the trial, the following court discipline will be read first."

"During the trial of the case, mobile phones and other communication tools should be turned off."

"No one is allowed to record or videotape without the permission of the court."

"No walking around at will."

"."

"Everyone stand up and invite the presiding judge and judges to enter the court!"

Everyone present stood up.

Zhang Lixia walked in first, followed closely by the two judges.

"Thank you, clerk, all sit down."

Under the auspices of Zhang Lixia, the identity information of the litigation participants began to be verified.

Small broken station platform.

Live broadcast room of a round-faced girl.

The trial of Wen Xuan's case was playing on the screen.

The number of people online in the live broadcast room has exceeded five figures.

"Zhang Lu, what do you think the final outcome of today's court hearing will be?"

As the barrage passed by, Zhang Ziyu shook her head: "I don't know either."

"Although we have discussed it many times in the live broadcast room before, it is all our own opinion."

"Judging from the facts found by the court of first instance, Wen Xuan definitely cannot escape the charge of intentional homicide."

"While I sympathize with her on a personal level, the law is the law."

"I hope the trial court will take into account the cause and try to give a light sentence."

As a lawyer who has not been practicing for a long time, Zhang Ziyu is also familiar with popular cases, large and small.

After learning about the Wen Xuan case for the first time, I have been paying attention to it until now.

This case has been discussed many times with the audience in the live broadcast room.

The second trial started today, and she deliberately spared time to watch the live broadcast of the trial with her friends.

Not just her, while the verification work in the court was going on, hundreds of thousands of pairs of eyes from all over the country were paying attention to the situation in this house through various platforms.

in court.

After verifying the information, Zhang Lixia began to ask about the avoidance situation.

"Defendant Wen Xuan, do you want to apply for recusal?"

"No application."

Wen Xuan shook her head.

"The plaintiff in the attached civil lawsuit is Zhang Kaishan. Do you want to apply for recusal?"

"No application."

Kaikaishan is Zhang Wenhai’s father and Wen Xuan’s former father-in-law.

After gritting his teeth and saying three words, Kaishan Shan leaned back on his chair and stared at Wen Xuan not far away.

Zhang Lixia nodded: "The court investigation will begin. Please ask the prosecutor to read out the indictment."

On the prosecution bench.

Huang Jing, who was wearing uniform, stood up, nodded to Zhang Lixia, and picked up the indictment.

"The defendant Wen Xuan, female, was born on XX, XX, 19XX. On suspicion of intentional homicide, he was criminally detained on XX, XX, 20XX, with the approval of this court."

"After legal review, it was found that at about 20:21 on June XX, [-]XX, the defendant Wen Xuan had a dispute with her husband, Zhang Wenhai, the victim in this case. During the quarrel, the two pushed each other and gradually escalated to beating each other. "

"During this process, the defendant Wen Xuan stabbed the victim Zhang Wenhai in the abdomen with a fruit knife on the coffee table in the living room, causing Zhang Wenhai to fall on the sofa. Then the defendant stabbed him several times."

“The evidence for establishing the above facts is as follows:

Physical evidence: evidence preservation list, seizure list, crime knife and photos, etc.;

Documentary evidence: household registration certificate, description of the situation, arrest process, etc.;

Witness testimony: the testimony of witnesses Li A, Xie B, etc.;

"

"This court believes that the defendant Wen Xuan illegally deprived others of their lives, and his behavior violated the provisions of Article 232 of my country's Criminal Law. The criminal facts are clear and the evidence is reliable and sufficient. His criminal responsibility should be pursued as intentional homicide." "According to my country's Criminal Procedure Law According to the provisions of Article 176, if a public prosecution is instituted, please be sentenced in accordance with the law!”

Huang Jing's voice fell, and many observers in the audience whispered.

Wen Mingyang and Jiang Xiuzhen looked at their daughter and held their hands tightly together.

Although they had already heard a similar indictment in the first instance and were well prepared, when the prosecutor read out the words "intentional homicide", their hearts trembled.

"Do the defendants and defense lawyers have any objections to the facts and charges charged in the indictment?"

All eyes turned to Wen Xuan.

Wen Xuan looked at Ren Zhen.

It's my turn to show up.
Ren Zhen took a deep breath, stood up, and bowed in the direction of Zhang Lixia.

Then, he looked at Huang Jing opposite.

Huang Jing suddenly felt a chill in his back.

"We have objections!"

Huang Jing's pupils shrank suddenly.

Have any objection? !

Are you kidding me?
Is this lawyer crazy?

The audience suddenly exploded.

clang clang-

Pick up the gavel and knock it three times.

"quiet!"

The majestic voice fell, and the court gradually became quiet.

Zhang Lixia frowned.

When a criminal case reaches the second trial stage, most of the circumstances are already very clear, and few defendants will raise objections to the facts and charges.

After all, the first-instance court has already tried it once. If there is really any problem, is it possible that the first-instance judge is a vegetarian?
Not to mention that before the case is sent to court, it has to go through many stages such as arrest approval, review and prosecution, etc. This is the result of many days of hard work by law enforcement and prosecutors.

Who dares to question?

"Defendant Wen Xuan, do you have any objection to the facts and charges charged in the indictment?"

in the live room.

Zhang Ziyu also looked surprised.

Wen Xuan's second-instance lawyer did not act according to common sense!
As soon as the trial began, such an unexpected move was made.

I don't know what kind of medicine he sells in the gourd?

"What's going on? Shouldn't it be said that I have no objections at this stage?"

"Indeed, the court trials I have seen before seem to have no objections, right?"

"Are you stupid? Didn't you hear that the presiding judge said a question instead of a hypothetical question?"

"If there are no objections, then what's the point of this problem?"

Seeing the barrage, Zhang Ziyu nodded: "Some friends have already answered it. The presiding judge's question is not for show. If you have any objections to the facts and charges in the indictment, you can raise it."

"It's just that in most court trials, the defendants have no objections. So some people will have preconceptions and think that this is just a formality. In fact, it is not."

"You've already asked me once, why are you asking me a second time?"

"Maybe the judge's ears are not very good?"

"I think you're not very good in your mind."

Zhang Ziyu also smiled: "Actually, if you listen carefully, you will find that the presiding judge's two questions are different."

"The first question was asked of the defendant, and the second question was asked of the defendant alone."

"In criminal cases, the perspectives of the defendant and the defense lawyer can be different. There are situations where the defendant pleads guilty but the defense lawyer pleads not guilty."

"So after lawyer Ren raised his objection, the presiding judge asked Wen Xuan separately just to confirm Wen Xuan's opinion."

"I see!"

"Yuanlu Niu! The little mouth is really good at talking!"

"What if he is a lawyer?"

"Whether or not you plead guilty seems to affect the court's sentencing, right? Then if Wen Xuan and the lawyer plead guilty and the other pleads not guilty, no matter what the judge decides, there will be no loss?"

"Is that so?"

Seeing the discussion on the barrage, Zhang Ziyu deliberately explained, and Wen Xuan's voice came from the live broadcast.

"I have objections!"

(End of this chapter)