If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 76: What does the pressure on me have to do with me?

Based on the existing evidence, it is simply impossible to support Li Kai's two views.

In fact, there is no such evidence.

When I, Shi Hao, accept an interview, do I still need permission from your company, Youen Company?

No need!

Who knew you'd call me for an interview?

And why didn't Shihao answer the call from Youen Company?

If you think about it with your buttocks, you will know that there was already a lot of unpleasantness between Shihao and Youen Company.

Even if Youen Company compensated Shi Hao 30 yuan, it was entirely due to the pressure of the public opinion storm, not that the other party suddenly woke up and changed his past.

Given this premise, what good can your company do by calling Shi Hao?
I'll just ignore the harassing calls.

However, this logic that a normal person can figure out turned out to be Shi Hao deliberately not answering the phone in the first trial, thereby putting pressure on Youen Company.

If you think about it carefully, you will find that these two views are completely based on the logic that Shi Hao committed a crime and deduced from the results.

We have all concluded that Shi Hao committed a crime. If we look at his behavior and thoughts based on the results, isn't there a problem everywhere?

I have always felt that there was a problem with Shi Hao's criminal intent in the original trial, but it was only now that the key was finally found!
Di Ming couldn't help but feel confused when he looked at Li Kai, who still looked depressed.

Are these guys just full of shit in their heads?

Can't you see such an obvious mistake?

Zhai Ming ignored that these views were originally raised by them or considered to be no problem after review.

The idea was wrong at the beginning, and it will only go further and further down this wrong line of thinking in the future, and it will be difficult to reverse it.

And if you think about it, you know that even if the lawyers of the first and second trials raised this issue, they would only be considered sophistry, and the rebuttal opinions would not be accepted at all.

The first point of accusation is biased, and it is not surprising that the road ahead will become more and more detours.

Shi Hao's imprisonment in recent years may have started here.

While feeling sorry for Shi Hao, Di Ming suddenly felt a little thankful that they had decided to lodge a protest with the court.

"But what this colleague just said makes sense. Whether Shi Hao has criminal intent cannot be judged solely by whether he took the initiative to contact Youen Company."

After criticizing Li Kai a little, Liu Lin seemed to have adopted some of Li Kai’s ideas:
"Although there is no direct evidence, after Shi Hao's interview with the TV station, Youen Company did contact Shi Hao again, and Shi Hao's refusal to answer the phone did objectively cause the pressure on Youen Company to increase. .

Prosecutor, do you have anything to add to this part? "

Do you understand what it means to be innocent beyond suspicion?
After complaining to Liu Lin in his mind, Zhai Ming could only shake his head: "From the existing evidence and facts, it is not certain that Youen Company's call to Shi Hao is necessarily related to Shi Hao's interview.

Even if this is true, but there is no evidence to prove it, I don't think there is a causal relationship between the two. "

Pretty!

Ren Zhen and Shi Hao looked at each other and gave Zhai Ming a thumbs up.

Look at other people, discuss things as they are, say whatever you have to say, this is the embodiment of justice!
"Defender, do you have anything to say?" After listening to Di Ming's words, Liu Lin had nothing to say and turned to look at Ren Zhen.

At the same time, I was also thinking in my mind, is it really hard to say whether this issue of criminal intent is really necessary?
"As for the pressure issue on Youen Company, the defender has something to add."

Ren Zhen's words lifted everyone's spirits.

The prosecutor couldn't prove that the pressure on Youen Company was caused by Shi Hao, so could this lawyer?

Seeing the helpless looks of this group of people, Shi Hao and Chang Jiahang looked at each other and smiled.

Want to peach?

Ren Yul is Shi Hao’s defender, right?
How could he possibly prove the facts against Shi Hao?

“After the Youen Company milk incident broke out in 20XX, as one of the few parents of children with the disease who had the courage to defend their rights, it was natural that Shi Hao received some media attention.

In fact, because of the problematic milk, some media are still paying attention to and reporting on related incidents to this day. Neither the media nor the public will be affected by the private compensation agreement reached between Youen Company and Shihao's family. Just forget about it. "

After hearing this, they realized that something was wrong, and several people in the auditorium remembered that the person speaking now was not on their team.

In other words, every word this guy says is to overturn the accusation/judgment they made.

Thinking of this, the four judges/public prosecutors felt as if they had eaten something they shouldn't have eaten.

"On June 20, 6XX, G City TV station broadcast a program. The theme of the program was Shi Hao's case of claiming compensation from Youen Company and telling consumers how to protect their rights. I think such a theme should be considered positive and positive. , in line with our public values.

For Shi Hao, this program tells his own personal experience and uses his own experience to remind consumers what they should pay attention to. This is not only the media's need to safeguard social public interests, but also Shi Hao's obligation as a citizen.

The Xincheng District Court subjectively speculated that Shi Hao's interview with the media and the need to buy Youen milk again because of the interview were deemed as his "criminal intention" to seek compensation again. In fact, he made up Shi Hao's thoughts based on his imagination, and then said this. Making inferences of guilt and making judgments based on such fictitious ideas seriously violates the basic principle of our country's criminal law that emphasizes facts and evidence. "

Even though he knew that Ren Zhen was speaking for him, Shi Hao's eyes widened.

Chang Jiahang even showed the enthusiasm he felt when he watched Ren Zhen's trial for the first time.

Saying in front of Li Kai that there is something wrong with his reasoning and judgment, isn't this a slap in the face?
So cool!
Li Kai's face was so gloomy that he was almost dripping with water, and Zhang Tian beside him was not much better.

Although he was not responsible for the trial, many of the opinions in the judgment were closely related to him.

After hitting Li Kai on the left side of his face, Zhang Tian's right side was swollen for a long time.

"And the so-called pressure problem at Youen Company was not actually caused by Shi Hao."

Seeing that the sky was turning cloudy in the auditorium, Ren Zhen sneered inwardly and continued:

“The pressure on Youen Company is caused by the mistakes they made.

This mistake was exposed by the media, and many people are still paying attention to it today. It can be said that the source of pressure on Youen Company is the company itself.

The defender believes that this pressure is positive and is a form of media supervision through public opinion.

Through the above discussion, I think it can be proved that Youen Company felt the pressure caused by its own behavior and took the initiative to go to Shi Hao, rather than the other way around, because it felt pressured by Shi Hao's interview and finally went to Shi Hao for negotiation.

The causal relationship is completely reversed, and the first instance found that Shi Hao had the so-called criminal intent, which was simply made up out of thin air! "

(End of this chapter)