If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 73 Everyone has objections
So Zhai Ming believed that, wrongly, it was the G City Public Prosecution Office that believed that Shi Hao's criminal intent in this case was unclear.

Is this the reason for their protest?
But no matter what, it can be regarded as giving Shi Hao a chance.

"Defender, which point do you have an objection to?"

Liu Lin did not ask Ren Zhen if he had any objections, but directly asked which one he had objections to.

It's impossible to have no objection anyway, so I'd better save my saliva.

"Everyone has objections."

Except for Shi Hao and Chang Jiahang, everyone was stunned.

Any objections?

what does that mean?
"Are you sure about this?"

Liu Lin confirmed.

Seeing Ren Zhen nodding, Liu Lin couldn't say anything else.

The four people in the auditorium looked at each other a few times, and they all saw the disbelief in each other's eyes.

Why is this lawyer Shi Haoxin looking for so tough?

These points in the first-instance judgment were jointly recognized by our Public Prosecution Office and the court.

Colleagues from the Public Prosecution Office of City G have different views on a certain point. Maybe they are high-level and think there is something wrong with our thinking.

That's justified.

This lawyer was very good, he directly rejected all our views.

You are better than us, right?

"Then we will focus on the objectionable parts of the case."

Liu Lin finally set the tone of the trial.

A judge next to him was muttering to himself: "They are all objections. Is there any point in this?"

"First of all, as to whether Shi Hao's criminal intention was generated under the guidance of Youen Company, the prosecutor just mentioned that he has objections. Please explain in detail."

After flipping through the materials for a long time, Liu Lin decided which question to start with.

“In the first instance, the prosecutor of the Xincheng District Public Prosecution Court believed that after Shi Hao reached a settlement agreement of 30 yuan with Youen Company, and before Youen Company contacted Shi Hao again, he had subjectively demanded 200 million yuan from Youen Company. intention and made a series of preparations for this.

Youen Company contacted Shi Hao only to provide Shi Hao with the opportunity to ask for 200 million, and did not create any criminal intent. "

Di Ming looked at this part of the original prosecutor's opinion and couldn't help but glance at the people in the auditorium:
"Our hospital believes that the logic is too far-fetched. Based on the existing evidence and materials alone, it can only be concluded that Shi Hao did accept an interview with the media after taking 30 yuan. However, this act of accepting an interview with the media is very It is difficult to determine that he has the intention to continue to claim 200 million."

Ren Zhen nodded. On this point, he and Di Ming had the same view.

Although there are still some details that can be added, the general direction is the same.

The same thing said by the prosecutor still carries more weight than what it said by the defender.

Liu Lin pulled out several pieces of evidence from the pile of materials in front of him and read them several times.

"According to the facts found in the original judgment, Shihao and Youen Company signed a "Compensation Agreement" on June 6 of the year when the case occurred, and received a compensation of 13 yuan on that day.

On June 6 of the same year, Shi Hao bought milk from Youen Company again and kept the receipt. On June 15, a TV station in G City broadcast a program containing Shi Hao's interview.

Based on this analysis, Shi Hao's criminal intention to demand 200 million yuan has already been established. "

Having said this, Liu Lin turned his head and glanced at the two judges beside him, and the three of them exchanged glances.

"With the above inference, does the prosecutor still believe that Shi Hao has no intention to continue claiming compensation?" Di Ming suddenly felt a little funny.

After being a public prosecutor for so many years, it seems that I have rarely been in this situation.

The prosecutor who was supposed to charge the defendant was overturning logic that was harmful to the defendant.

The judge's questions to him were more like questions to the defense lawyer.

But I'm just doing my job.

That's it.

"No."

Zhai Ming shook his head: "If Shi Hao had the intention to continue claiming compensation, he should have made his request to Youen Company in a more direct way instead of accepting an interview."

"Let's assume for the time being that Shi Hao has committed a crime. If we think according to this logic, can Youen Company give Shi Hao more compensation by simply accepting an interview with a TV station?"

"I think according to normal people's thinking, it is obviously impossible."

Liu Lin glanced at the two colleagues next to him again, making Ren Zhen speechless.

Is you really the presiding judge?
Why do you always look at others?

It is understandable to seek the opinions of other judges. After all, we are a collegial panel.

But you don’t need to discuss every issue with others, right?
However, Di Ming's answer also made Ren Zhen confused.

After Shi Hao received the compensation, he was interviewed again, indicating that he had the intention to continue to claim compensation.

This is the logic of the first instance court on this issue.

It sounds reasonable at first glance, but if you think about it carefully, it is completely untenable, right?

How come this point is so firmly established?
Would it be too hasty?
It would not be incomprehensible if it was just one point that was not studied carefully, but many sloppinesses appeared at the same time, sending Shi Hao directly to prison. This cannot be described as sloppy.

In the days before the trial, Ren Zhen almost tore through the judgments and all the materials of the first and second trials, and could not find a reasonable legal explanation for many issues.

"Regarding this issue, let's listen to what the person in charge of the first instance of this case said to help us make an accurate judgment. Prosecutors and defenders, what are your opinions?"

Liu Lin looked at Di Ming and then at Ren Zhen.

Soliciting the opinions of the original judge and prosecutor will inevitably have an impact on the retrial judge, and is theoretically inconsistent with the regulations.

But if you understand the situation, it doesn’t seem impossible?

Although there was no clear provision, Ren Zhen knew that even if it was not stated openly, they would still ask what they should ask outside the court, so they gave up the idea of ​​raising objections.

"can."

After a brief hesitation, Di Ming agreed with Liu Lin's decision.

He did not directly handle this case five years ago. Although the case also went to the G City Public Prosecution Court at that time, their court only sent personnel to appear in court, and the specific prosecutorial duties were performed by the person in charge of the first instance.

Therefore, he could basically only get the situation from the first instance on paper.

Before the trial, he also talked with the public prosecutor who handled the case in the hospital at that time, but did not get any additional effective information.

However, since he could find someone outside the court to understand the situation, it was not so abrupt for the court to find the organizer of the first trial.

With this thought, Zhai Ming naturally had no reason to refuse.

Seeing Ren Zhen nodding, Liu Lin looked towards the auditorium with satisfaction.

(End of this chapter)