If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 48 Obligation Urgent
As soon as Ren Zhen said these words, Wang Feng was stunned.

"Ah? Why am I lost again?"

"What the prosecutor is saying is that there was no violation of the obligation to rescue, but it was a violation of the obligation not to drive after drinking, so it does not constitute a conflict?"

"rational!"

"What the lawyer is saying is, does it constitute a conflict of legal obligations if it violates both the obligation to rescue and the obligation not to drink and drive?"

"It makes sense!"

"Sounds the same?"

"Nonsense, the lawyer's premise is that if you think according to the prosecutor's logic, it is actually the prosecutor's intention. Can it be different?"

"When the lawyer said this, I really want to find out what's wrong?"

Netizens who were confused by Wang Feng and Ren Zhen seemed to have some clues at this time.

"Lawyer Ren actually went through the prosecutor's logic again and listed the conflicts of obligations under this logic from a negative perspective."

Zhang Ziyu was thoughtful, not knowing whether she was explaining to the audience or convincing herself.

“This logic may sound okay at first glance, but if you think about it carefully, it actually doesn’t hold true at all.

If Zhao Kai did not fulfill his obligation to rescue the child, there would be no need to drive a motor vehicle while drunk.

But if Zhao Kai drives his child to the hospital after drinking, he will definitely not violate his father's obligation to rescue his son. "

Zhang Ziyu's eyes lit up.

Therefore, the prosecutor's logic is essentially rogue.

No wonder Lawyer Ren said he was sophistry!
Zhang Ziyu's explanation made some netizens suddenly realize.

Of course, more people still haven’t figured it out.

After all, this logic is indeed too convoluted. If Ren Zhen hadn't emphasized it by giving a counterexample, even a legal person like Zhang Ziyu would not have realized that it was wrong at the first time.

In the court, the judge also heard what Ren Zhen meant and couldn't help but give Wang Feng a look.

How can such a view be expressed in court?

In Xu Yangfan's opinion, Wang Feng seemed to be using any means necessary to convict him.

Although it is understandable due to the nature of the work, it also depends on the situation.

Is it necessary to pursue this case so fiercely?
Ren Zhen broke his logic and Wang Feng clenched his hands tightly, obviously feeling very uneasy.

"The conflict mentioned by the prosecutor does not exist at all, so the logic is obviously wrong."

Ren Zhen looked calm and unhurried:
"The actual legal logic is that Zhao Kai's son has a high fever and Zhao Kai is facing a dangerous situation stipulated by the law. At this time, he has two choices before him."

A finger was raised, then slowly flattened, pointing at the sleeping child in Du Jingjing's arms in the auditorium:

"First, he ignored the child's high fever and allowed it to burn down, waiting for the ambulance to come or waiting for a taxi before going to the hospital. In this case, Zhao Kai is a legal citizen who does not drink and drive."

The corner of Xu Yangfan's mouth twitched.

This lawyer is too bad.

Isn't this equivalent to saying that according to the prosecutor's logic, Zhao Kai is a cold-blooded and ruthless but law-abiding person?

Under such circumstances, Zhao Kai is a good boy who abides by the law, but where do you put the law?

Is the law cold and without warmth?
Ren Zhen's words seemed to portray the image of a cold-blooded father, but in fact they were secretly poking Wang Feng's spine.

The second finger was raised and pointed at Zhao Kai in the dock:

"Second, when the ambulance could not arrive in time and he could not get a taxi, he took the risk of drunk driving on the road, just to get his son out of danger in time. At this time, Zhao Kai was an illegal citizen who was drunk and driving. Even a criminal suspect suspected of dangerous driving!" Ren Zhenyi spoke sternly. Just listening to these words, those who didn't know it thought he was the prosecutor, who was righteously accusing the hateful guy in the dock.

"but"

Ren Zhen's tone suddenly calmed down: "He is also a good father and husband who loves his children and cares about his family."

In the auditorium, Du Jingjing held her child in one hand and covered her mouth with the other hand, trying her best to hold back her cries.

But the tears in his eyes flowed down uncontrollably.

Fear, grievance, uneasiness.

All kinds of emotions were mixed together. Under the tremendous pressure of the trial, this woman who only knew how to care for her husband and raise her children finally couldn't bear it anymore.

"Honey, don't cry."

The fat on Zhao Kai's face was also a little moist. He saw his wife turning her face to the side, fearing that her son's clothes would be wet with tears, and he suddenly panicked.

Ugh.
Everyone present, including the netizens watching the live broadcast, sighed inwardly.

Send your son to the hospital, why is it as serious as murder?
This thought has appeared in many people's minds.

"Therefore, the defendant Zhao Kai did not face a conflict of obligations that night."

Ren Zhen walked a few steps and handed Du Jingjing a pack of tissues while continuing to talk.

Regarding his behavior of leaving the table without authorization, Xu Yangfan just glanced at him and acquiesced.

"In fact, after discovering that his son had a high fever, Zhao Kai was already caught between two legal obligations.

The child's condition is so critical, he must be sent to the hospital, right? "

Ren Zhen pointed to the evidence on the screen: "So Zhao Kai and his wife first called an ambulance and then took a taxi.

When neither of these two actions can solve the immediate dilemma, the obligation to rescue has already been placed on Zhao Kai's head.

It was precisely because of this that Zhao Kai drove himself and took his son to the hospital. "

Under Ren Zhen's analysis, things became clearer and clearer.

“And his decision was prompted by the legal obligation to rescue between father and son.

Although Zhao Kai did not have this awareness when he made this decision, because he could not sit here and think about the legal nature of his behavior like us.

But this does not affect that Zhao Kai's behavior of driving a motor vehicle while drunk has been designated by the legal rescue obligation from the beginning! "

"Unfortunately, this act, which was carried out under legal obligations, violated another law!"

"So it's not like you violated one obligation and complied with another?"

"Actually, that's correct, but in more detail, while complying with one legal obligation, it also violated another legal obligation."

"Transparent!"

"Low-key, low-key, spicy!"

"I said the lawyer was very transparent. What does he care about?"

"But I am uneducated, so I left a sentence to show my respect!"

"This lawyer is awesome, pay attention!"

"Then I'll thank you on behalf of Yuan Lv and Ren Lv."

"Does the prosecutor still believe that the defendant did not face a conflict of legal obligations on the night of the incident?"

(End of this chapter)