You became a lawyer and sent the judge in?

Chapter 310 Vice Dean, do you want to send yourself in?
Xu Bo wants to refute?
He wants to refute!

After all, this is a live trial.

The public opinion about this case was so loud, and the other party's remarks completely made him criticized.

But how to refute?

This was his original thought. All criminal suspects were on Jiang Wei.

So why is Jiang Wei not a criminal?
Xu Bo has been a public prosecutor for so many years and has handled hundreds of cases.

99% of the time, the suspects point to the same person.

The criminal in this case is the suspect!

In this case, let’s not talk about anything else.

Shan said why all the suspicions pointed to Jiang Wei.

Including the clothes left behind and whereabouts at that time, why couldn't Jiang Wei explain these?
Or why no one can prove that Jiang Wei did not commit the crime at that time?
what is the reason?
The reason is that Jiang Wei committed a crime!
Isn't this an obvious fact? !
There is nothing else to discuss, there is no room for discussion at all!

Xu Bo didn't know how to refute Su Bai's questioning in the court hearing.

So he raised his hand directly to indicate:

"The appellant entrusted a lawyer to state matters unrelated to the trial at the trial."

"The statement made by the lawyer entrusted by the appellant just now involves questioning me personally."

"So I applied to the presiding judge for the appellant to appoint a lawyer to stop interfering and questioning my personal issues, and to give me a corresponding warning!"

???

Facing Xu Bo's rebuttal, Su Bai was stunned for a moment.

What does it mean to state content that is not relevant to the trial?

It can be clearly seen from the clear side of this case that the prosecutor believes that Jiang Wei is the murderer.

Therefore, we have been emphasizing other contents, such as the remaining clothes that are not direct evidence.

Furthermore.

The Supreme People's Procuratorate has intervened and stated that there are no objective facts and no objective evidence to prove that Jiang Wei committed a crime.

It stands to reason that as a public prosecutor, you should refer to the opinions of the Supreme People's Procuratorate, right?

General overturning involves the Supreme People's Procuratorate.

This means that under certain circumstances, no other proof of guilt can be found in this case.

In this case, Xu Bo still wanted to accuse Jiang Wei.

???

why?
Of course, Su Bai knew what Xu Bo was thinking about.

Most of the unjust, false and wrongful convictions occurred because the law enforcement officers or prosecutors at the time identified the only suspect.

In this case, Xu Bo created the illusion that all situations were like this.

Actually?
Actually not!
Among the probability of such cases, the proportion of unjust, false and wrongful convictions is small, but that does not mean that there are none!
This is also the reason why procedural justice has always been emphasized in the judiciary.

Because procedural justice is emphasized, the possibility of certain unjust, false, and wrongful convictions is eliminated.
.
....
Su Bai was about to refute Xu Bo, when the presiding judge Shen Yao, who was sitting on the bench, sounded the hammer.

Boom boom boom!
"The questioning by the lawyer entrusted by the appellant is not relevant to the issues in this trial."

“Here is a reminder to the lawyers entrusted by the appellant.”

???

remind?

Looking at the presiding judge with a serious face in the court hearing.

Okay... just remind me.

Su Bai didn't care too much about this issue.

It can only be seen that the presiding judge is obviously biased in favor of the prosecutor.

but.…

Having said that, no matter whether the presiding judge favors the prosecutor or not in this case.

In this case of public hearing.

Especially when the Supreme People's Procuratorate intervenes and requests a retrial.

If the prosecutor cannot produce direct evidence, then the case must be overturned!

Don’t turn it over?

cough cough...

Su Bai glanced at Li Xuezhen.

Li Xuezhen was turning back and forth between the prosecutor's seat and the trial bench with gleaming eyes.
.
....
At the trial table, Shen Yao continued to speak:
"Based on the pleas just made by the appellant and the prosecution."

"Now the collegial panel has made relevant conclusions."

“In response to the appeal with the appellant, the basis for finding Jiang Wei’s innocence is——

First, there are no objective facts and no objective evidence.

Second, illegal evidence was found in Jiang Wei’s first and second trials. "

"The public prosecutor's opinion is that the possibility of Jiang Wei committing a crime cannot be ruled out."

"Does the parties have any objections to the above summary?"

The presiding judge summarized these points very well, so Su Bai and Xu Bo had no objections.

Immediately afterwards, Shen Yao spoke again, but this time she was questioning the prosecutor:

"In his statement just now, the prosecutor said that he increased the suspect Jiang Wei's criminal suspicion."

"But in the whole case, I want to prove Jiang Wei's criminal suspicion..."

"The clothes left behind cannot be used to prove Jiang Wei's suspicion of crime."

"Because the clothing left behind does not prove that it was left behind after the crime."

"Does the prosecutor know this in his heart?"

Su Bai was stunned for a moment by the presiding judge's questioning of the prosecutor.

???

What is the presiding judge doing?

Just now, you were still rejecting the application for recusal, but now you are directly pointing the finger of the problem at the prosecutor?

Su Bai didn't understand something about the presiding judge's actions.

Facing the presiding judge's question, Xu Bo slowly spoke:
"In this case, all suspicions point to Jiang Wei."

"And there is witness testimony and indirect evidence."

"Furthermore, Jiang Wei has not ruled out his own criminal suspicion at all."

Xu Bo changed the subject when facing the presiding judge's question.

"So is there any direct evidence to prove that Jiang Wei committed a crime?"

At the trial table, Shen Yao asked again.

"No."

Xu Bo spoke: "This case occurred 13 years ago, when evidence was being collected."

"No DNA from the victim related to the perpetrator was collected."

"So there is no direct evidence to prove it."

"Then you mean that in this case, there is only relevant circumstantial evidence such as witness testimony, which is ambiguous."

"There is no relevant direct evidence to prove that Jiang Wei was the perpetrator at that time, right?"

"Yes, Judge."

After hearing Xu Bo's answer, Shen Yao looked at the client Jiang Wei again at the trial table.

"Now we are going to check some circumstances with the parties concerned and ask for their cooperation."

Jiang Wei turned his head and glanced at Su Bai, feeling a little uneasy in his heart.

how to say.

After all, this case was finally retried, and we had gone through so much in the trial just now.

Especially the confrontation between Su Bai and the presiding judge.

When Jiang Wei faced the presiding judge, he was a little nervous, for fear that something else would happen and the case would be lost.

If you lose the lawsuit...

He couldn't afford the consequences...
So he couldn't help but look at Su Bai subconsciously.

but.…

After seeing Su Bai nodding to tell him not to worry, Jiang Wei's heart became calmer and he nodded:
"Okay, presiding judge."

Shen Yao's eyes fell on Jiang Wei.

She also learned about this case in detail.As the presiding judge, she knew what Xu Bo was thinking.

I also know what the key points of this case are.

The key point in this case is whether Jiang Wei is the real perpetrator.

If Jiang Wei is the real criminal, then because he entrusted a lawyer to defend the criminal in court, he has always used the law.

So is it fair to the victims?unfair!

Thinking of this, Shen Yao, as the presiding judge, asked:
"Based on evidence provided by law enforcement and prosecutors."

"The piece of clothing you had at that time was in your own home. You even wore that piece of clothing walking around the village two days ago..."

"These have all been confirmed."

"You can't explain why your clothes appeared in the victim's house, can you?"

Jiang Wei looked sad: "Yes!"

"I don't know why my clothes were at the victim's house."

"I remember that I had worn that piece of clothing at that time, and then I put it somewhere and couldn't find it."

"And then showed up at the victim's home."

"I don't know why your clothes appeared in the victim's house, and I can't explain your whereabouts that night."

"No one can confirm where you went, right?"

Shen Yao continued to ask.

"Yes...I went out for a walk that night when I had nothing to do. It's strange, I always met people when I went out for a walk."

"But that night, I went out for a walk and didn't meet anyone."

"No one can confirm where I went."

"According to what you said, you can't prove that you are not suspected of committing a crime, right?"

"Yes presiding judge."

"Ok!"

Shen Yao nodded and turned to look at the other two members of the collegial panel.

This case has progressed to this point. In fact, the relevant circumstances have become very clear.

There are only two points in this case -

First, there is no direct evidence to prove that Jiang Wei committed a crime.

Second, all criminal suspicions point to Jiang Wei, and Jiang Wei has no evidence to prove that he has not committed a crime.

The case has reached a deadlock.

Is the criminal Jiang Wei?
Regarding this point, Shen Yao could not judge and still needed to listen to the opinions of the other two members of the collegial panel.

So the hammer was struck.

"Adjourn!"
.
....
Adjournment…

During recess.

Some doubtful questions also cropped up in various legal commentary live broadcast rooms.

For example, why does the prosecutor continue to refute the plea.

And this time, the trial was adjourned for no apparent reason.

These two points are the most concerning content when watching the live broadcast of this court trial.

Regarding these two points, someone in the live broadcast room also gave relevant explanations.

"The prosecutor continued to refute. Firstly, it was to reduce his own responsibility. Secondly, Jiang Wei was indeed suspected. Thirdly, it might be the reason mentioned by lawyer Su."

"As for why the court was adjourned..."

"Actually, this case has progressed to this point. There is nothing more to say. The adjournment should be to discuss the verdict."

With someone explaining, everyone in the live broadcast room was also looking forward to the verdict of this reversal of the case.
.
....
On the other hand, this is the second adjournment of this case.

The first adjournment is to discuss whether to agree to apply for recusal.

This second adjournment is to discuss related penalty and judgment issues.

As for the judgment in this case, in fact, the collegial panel knew about the case from the beginning.

It is also very clear what is the most important thing about this case.

It is nothing more than what Su Bai stated without direct evidence and illegal evidence.

For the time being, there is no direct evidence to add that Jiang Wei has committed a crime.

As for the signature of illegal evidence...

how to say.…

Shen Yao didn't quite understand the signature of this illegal evidence.

Because most of the unjust, false and wrongful convictions are due to coercion.

Use certain means to get suspects to admit their crimes.

And there will be no clues or evidence left behind for many years, making it impossible to trace.

It is very difficult to reverse the verdict.

Therefore, forging evidence like Jiang Wei’s case is rare!
Shen Yao spoke:
"...The relevant evidence has been seen before..."

"This trial...to be honest, there's not much to say in terms of the evidence."

"What do you two think?"

Li Xiangqian and Ma Da have similar views on this case to Shen Yao.

This case...

how to say.

In terms of evidence, there are indeed deficiencies.

But at this time, Ma Da came up with a point of view——

"The biggest shortcoming of this case is that there is no direct evidence."

"But there is no fact that can prove that Jiang Wei has not committed any crime."

"So... I think if you think about it from this aspect, there are many aspects involved in this case."

Shen Yao nodded in agreement: "Actually, this issue is also the most critical issue I consider."

Then he turned to look at Li Qianqian: "What do you think?"

Regarding this issue, Li Xiangqian, Shen Yao and Ma Da have different views.

Li Xiangqian spoke: "This case is a retrial case..."

"We need to make a judgment based on the evidence as to whether the person concerned is guilty and whether the case should be overturned."

"In the absence of direct evidence, it is impossible to clear Jiang Wei's suspicion."

"But he cannot be found guilty."

"In this case, the verdict should be overturned, right?"

After Li Xiangqian expressed his thoughts, Shen Yao frowned slightly.

to be honest.…

Whether this case can be overturned or not, in her opinion, depends on certain circumstances.

This case is not a verdict of guilty or not guilty, but a retrial of the case from that year.

In other words, can Jiang Wei be given a clean slate...
In Shen Yao's heart, she was leaning towards the prosecutor.

"we'll see.…"

Hearing Shen Yao speak, Li Qianqian frowned slightly.

???

What does it mean to look again?

This case is already clear, there is no evidence and no facts.

If the Supreme People's Procuratorate intervenes, what will happen if the case is not overturned?

Watch again?What to see?
Want to send yourself in?

This trial was a live trial, although there were some conflicts when I applied for recusal just now.

But you don’t want to catch yourself because of this, right?

Li Xiangqian originally wanted to say something, but Shen Yao continued:
"I have a good idea about this case..."

After hearing this, Li Xiangqian breathed a sigh of relief.

As the vice-president of the High Court, it’s good to be measured.

Otherwise...it would be completely sending yourself inside!
.
....
PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

(End of this chapter)