Grassroots lawyers also have spring

Chapter 793

"The defendant presents evidence!" said the female judge.

"The first piece of evidence, the dormitory management system and duty schedule, proves that the defendant manages the dormitory building, and non-unit personnel are not allowed to enter or leave without registration. The dormitory is a private area for employees, and it is strictly forbidden to enter other people's dormitories.

The second piece of evidence, the bed purchase invoice, proves that the beds purchased by the defendant are all from regular manufacturers with excellent quality.

The proof is over! "Wang Chuan said.

"Plaintiff, apart from the national standards on bunk beds that you have provided, are there any other mandatory standards formulated by the state?" asked the female judge.

"No! We didn't find any other documents. But even if there is no national standard, we still think there are safety hazards in going up and down the bed ladder." The old lawyer defended.

In fact, Wang Chuan also knows the bed use standards proposed by Wang Chuan, but he thinks that even if the "Main Size of Beds" GB3328-82 is invalid, "Household Bunk Bed Safety Part One: Requirements" GB24430.1-2009 can also be referred to Get used to it.He planned to beat the old master to death with random punches, first he gave a combination of punches, and threw out the useful and useless ones, and let the judge check it out himself!

But he didn't expect the defendant's lawyer to investigate so carefully, it's not easy to be a lawyer!A lawyer's belly is comparable to a grocery store, and he needs to know a little bit about everything!Why!Tired!

"Defendant, what does the ladder look like in the dormitory? Do you have any photos?" The female judge looked at Wang Chuan. The only way to judge whether there was a safety hazard was to look at the real thing.

"I have a photo of the dormitory here. The bunk beds purchased by the defendant are the ones where people sleep on the top and a table is placed on the bottom for study, that is, the top bunk and the desk. A step ladder is installed between the two adjacent beds to facilitate getting in and out of the bed. .” After Wang Chuan submitted the photos of the bed to the judge, the judge handed one of them to the plaintiff.

"Plaintiff, please confirm, is it this kind of bed?" the female judge asked.

"Yes, the plaintiff used this kind of bed." The old lawyer said.

"Well, let's find a time in the courtroom. Both of you and I will go to the scene with me to see the real thing. The trial will continue." The female judge said.

"Plaintiff, you claim that you slipped and fell from a ladder, why did the admission record say that you fell from the bed and caused scalp hematoma and left hip injury as a result of the occipital injury?" the female judge looked through the medical records and asked.

"The contents of the admission record are not all true. At that time, the plaintiff did not suffer any head injuries. It was caused by the defendant falling down and wanting to get up and knocking on the table.

You look at the admission history and it says that you slipped and fell from a ladder when you went to bed.The plaintiff's colleagues all knew about it. It was the hospital where two of his colleagues sent him to at that time, and the records in the medical history were also mentioned by his colleagues. "Obviously, the old lawyer had expected that the female judge would ask such a question, so he had already planned his speech.

Although the admission records are not good for the plaintiff, the records in the medical history can still be used, and the records in the medical history are said by an irrelevant third person. The old lawyer thought that the words of the irrelevant third person should be more credible than the plaintiff's self-justification , the judge will probably believe it.

"When the plaintiff fell, was anyone else present?" The female judge looked at the old lawyer.

"No, the plaintiff was the only person in the dormitory at the time. The plaintiff called for help after falling down. Two colleagues from the next door ran over to call the emergency center, and then an ambulance pulled the plaintiff away. Those two colleagues went with her at the time. Hospital." The old lawyer said.

"That is to say, there was only the plaintiff in the dormitory at the time of the incident, and no one saw how the plaintiff fell, is that true?" said the female judge.

"Yes." The old lawyer said.

"Is that so? The defendant!" The female judge looked at Wang Chuan.

"That's right, the plaintiff was the only one in the dormitory at the time. The two employees next door also heard from the plaintiff that he slipped and fell from the ladder and injured himself, but they didn't see it with their own eyes." Wang Chuan said.

He secretly laughed in his heart: the admission record was told by the patient (that is, the plaintiff), while the medical history was told by the two colleagues next door to the plaintiff. Comparing these two pieces of evidence, plus the fact that the plaintiff did not dare to admit that he had an occipital injury , the closest to the truth is that conceivable.

"Was the plaintiff conscious when he was sent to the hospital?" The female judge looked at the old lawyer in the plaintiff's seat.

"Clear! Clear consciousness!" said the old lawyer.

He really wanted to say that the plaintiff was knocked out and unconscious, but he didn't know how the plaintiff called for help in the dormitory, and how did he cooperate with the doctor's admission records?Obviously can't justify itself.Besides, as long as the judge asks the two employees, the matter will be fully understood, so let's be honest.

……

It was past 01:30 when Wang Chuan walked out of the courtroom.The court opened at nine o'clock in the morning and continued until 01:30 in the afternoon. When he finally went out, Wang Chuan's stomach was growling.

The female judge finally determined the time for the on-site inspection to be [-]:[-] pm the next day, and the lawyers of both sides agreed with the judge's schedule.

Wang Chuan asked He Bin to find a restaurant to eat first, and sat in the car. Wang Chuan called Chang Xingyue, General Manager of the Legal Department of ZJ Bureau [-], told him about the trial, and asked him to arrange someone to cooperate with the judge in the afternoon of the day after tomorrow. Dormitory site survey.The latter said that he would arrange for Xiao Hu to deal with the matter.

Returning to the law firm in the afternoon, Wang Chuan happened to see Fu Ziwen head-on, and remembered the non-performing asset project in Guangdong Province invested by Brother Pan Er.

"Fu Lv, what are you busy with?" Wang Chuan asked with a smile.

"Pan Lu Company has another project in the pharmaceutical industry. I am going to go to Guangdong Province with Pan Lu to see the project tomorrow morning.

The non-performing asset project we invested in before has already started to go through the procedures and is preparing to auction the collateral.I will go to the court tomorrow after watching the project with Pan Lu, and urge the judge to submit the auction as soon as possible. " Fu Ziwen knew what Wang Chuan meant and reported it.

"Okay, we need to pay close attention to this project. This is the first time our law firm has invested in a project. We must hit the ground running! I will wait for your good news." Wang Chuan said with a smile.

"Okay! Don't worry, this is our hard-earned money, I will keep an eye on it." Fu Ziwen laughed.

A day later, Wang Chuan went to the ZJ Division [-] for litigation according to the time appointed by the judge before, and Xiao Hu arrived earlier than Wang Chuan.

"Lawyer Wang, this is Manager Zheng of our company's purchasing department. He purchased all the beds. Let him introduce the beds used in the dormitory to the judge later. He knows more." Xiao Hu said.

Wang Chuan was looking for an insider to introduce the bed, and Manager Zheng from the Purchasing Department was exactly what he wanted, so he nodded and agreed.

The judge, the lawyers of both parties and Xiao Hu went down to the plaintiff's dormitory under the leadership of Manager Zheng and the dormitory manager.

"Defendant and plaintiff's attorney, are you sure that the plaintiff lives in this dormitory?" The female judge looked at the old lawyer and Wang Chuan.

"Yes, this is the dormitory. That's right!" said the two agents.

(End of this chapter)