Grassroots lawyers also have spring

Chapter 131 Cross-examination
"Evidence [-], the marriage certificates of the plaintiff and the defendant, Mr. Zhao, prove that the two parties are legally husband and wife.

Evidence [-], the bank transfer records between the two defendants, proves that there is a gift of money between the two defendants and the specific amount.

Evidence [-], the letter of repentance written by the defendant, Mr. Zhao, proves that there is an improper relationship between the two defendants, and that they work in the same unit. Ms. Yun is fully aware of Mr. Zhao's family situation.

..." Wang Chuan read the catalog of evidence.

"Scribe, give me the calculator!" The fat judge held the bank transfer record, looked around the table with his eyes, and said to the clerk who was taking notes.

The clerk got up and handed the calculator to the fat judge.

"Plaintiff, have you added the amount in the bank transfer records? Are you sure it is the requested amount?" The fat judge asked while tapping the calculator with his chubby fingers, summing up on the spot.

"Judge, we've calculated it, and it's 27 yuan." Wang Chuan said.

"That's not right! How come the number I calculated is bigger than yours! It's 32 yuan." The fat judge said loudly after typing on the calculator.

Wang Chuan broke out in sweat when he heard it, and his face was bewildered: Why is there so much extra money!Do you think you are bad?Can't!

This is not a trivial matter. If the client knows that his attorney has miscalculated, and undercounted by more than 5 yuan, the client's face will probably be ugly, and the lawyer will be scolded!
Even if you don't say it clearly, the client will point at the lawyer's spine and yell at him behind his back, and the trust that has been built up with great difficulty will be in vain, and this business line will be considered broken!

"Judge, the defendant, Ms. Yun, also transferred money to the defendant, Mr. Zhao, about 5 yuan. We deducted it to get 27 yuan. We have already drawn it with a yellow pen." Zheng Yi Seeing Wang Chuan's confused face, he said hastily.

After finishing speaking, Zheng Yi patted Wang Chuan's arm with his hands to show comfort!
"Are you talking about these two parts? The yellow part? One sum is more than 8000, and the sum is more than 1000." After receiving Zheng Yi's affirmation, the judge tapped the calculator to sum up: "Well, the total is [-] Zero one hundred yuan. Two offsets..., that's it, no problem."

"Defendant Yunlin cross-examines evidence." The fat judge turned to look at the old lawyer and said indifferently.

"We recognize the authenticity, relevance, and legality of Evidence [-]; we recognize the authenticity and relevance of Evidence [-], but not its legality. We do not recognize the authenticity, legitimacy, and relevance of Evidence [-]. "The old lawyer thought up the cross-examination opinion when the fat judge was doing simple addition and subtraction math problems.

"Defendant, what is the reason for your disapproval of the legality of the second evidence?" the fat judge asked the old lawyer.

"We believe that bank transfer records belong to personal privacy. The plaintiff used other people's privacy as evidence, which obviously violated other people's privacy. This evidence is illegal." The old lawyer said.

The fat judge turned his head to look at the plaintiff's seat: "Plaintiff, how did you obtain the bank transfer records for evidence two?"

"Judge, the second evidence provided by the plaintiff, the bank transfer records were provided by the defendant Mr. Zhao voluntarily to the plaintiff. We believe that the second evidence is legal. The method of obtaining it is legal." Wang Chuan said under the instruction of Zheng Yi.

"Defendant Zhao Zhicheng, is that so?" The fat judge looked at the female lawyer.

"Yes, the second bank transfer record provided by the plaintiff was provided by the defendant." The female lawyer simply replied.

In fact, this problem can be understood after a little thought. The plaintiff Ms. Wang and the defendant Mr. Zhao are husband and wife. After the affair was revealed, Mr. Zhao was afraid that Ms. Wang would recruit directly, so he told the plaintiff everything.The plaintiff naturally asked the defendant Mr. Zhao to print out the bank records of the payment for verification.

Does the disheartened Mr. Zhao dare not provide the bank statement?Ms. Wang is a lot of vegetarians, if he doesn't provide a meal of pros and cons, plus a meal of Jiuyin White Bone Claw, it is estimated that Mr. Zhao will not be able to get out of bed for at least half a month.In the end, you have to leave the house!
"The defendant, Zhao Zhicheng, cross-examined the evidence." The fat judge didn't dwell on this issue, and said directly.

"We recognize the authenticity, legality, and relevance of the evidence provided by the plaintiff."

"Second defendant, do you have any evidence to submit?" the fat judge asked.

"Judge, the defendant Yunlin has evidence to submit. The first evidence is the invoice for the purchase of home appliances, which proves that during the time when the two defendants lived together, the defendant Ms. Yun used the money given by the defendant Mr. Zhao to buy home appliances, a total of more than 5000.

Evidence [-], the rental contract, the defendant, Ms. Yun, rented a one-bedroom apartment to live with Mr. Zhao, which proves that part of the money given by the defendant, Mr. Zhao, was used for living together. "The old lawyer said and submitted the evidence to the judge, the plaintiff and another defendant in three copies.

"The plaintiff cross-examines evidence." The fat judge said after reviewing the evidence.

"The authenticity, legality, and relevance of Evidence [-] are not recognized. We found that one of the invoices of Evidence [-] was issued more than two years ago, and there was no improper relationship between the two defendants at that time. The other invoice The content is three air conditioners, a one-bedroom apartment needs three air conditioners? We believe that evidence [-] was improvised by the defendant. Therefore, it should not be admitted.

The authenticity, legitimacy and relevance of Evidence [-] shall not be recognized.The rental contract is signed between two natural persons, whether it is a real lease, whether the rent is paid, and there is no relevant evidence to support it, we will not recognize it.

Moreover, whether Ms. Yun, the defendant, paid the rent with the donated money or with her own income, there is no way to tell just by a lease contract.

In addition, even if Ms. Yun lives alone, she still needs to rent a house. It is normal for her to rent a one-bedroom house to live by herself.Therefore, we do not accept the proof purpose of this evidence. "

After Wang Chuan and Zheng Yi reviewed the evidence and exchanged briefly, Wang Chuan confronted him.

Seeing that the plaintiff's lawyer picked out so many faults, the old lawyer panicked: Oops!I didn't look carefully at the certificate given by the client, I was negligent!
"Defendant Yunlin's attorney, how long has there been an improper relationship between the two defendants?" the fat judge asked.

"Well... It should be more than two years!" The old lawyer was uncertain.

"Defendant Zhao Zhicheng's attorney, do you know?" the fat judge asked.

"It's not that long. According to my understanding, it's about a year and a half." The female lawyer said.

"Judge, the improper relationship between the two defendants should be one year and five months." Wang Chuan said: "It is in the defendant's confession. Moreover, the defendant Ms. Yun joined the company where the defendant Mr. Zhao works for no more than two years." Years, they didn't know each other before. You can go to the unit to investigate."

The judge nodded: "Defendant Yunlin's agent, after the court, provide the specific time when Xia Yunlin joined the company. After the court, we will go to the unit to investigate and collect evidence."

"Defendant Zhao Zhicheng, do you have any evidence to submit?" The fat judge continued with an official expression.

"Judge, we have no evidence to submit." The female lawyer said.

(End of this chapter)