Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 337
In an instant, the situation was turbulent again.Utsunomiya once again shaken Kitahara's evidence by pointing out that in the case of sentence reading in the two originals, he revealed the other side of the truth.This fierce counterattack once again shows that the Oriental authority on intellectual property law in front of him is by no means a sick tiger.

Hearing this sentence, the judges in the referee's seat also looked at the plaintiff's seat.

After all, if a considerable part of Xiachuan's proofreading comes from the sentence readings that existed in ancient books, then the originality of the proofreading will be challenged.

The expression on Bei Yuan's face did not change, but he took out a piece of paper from the plaintiff's seat behind him, glanced at him, and heard him say in a steady voice, "Chief referee, the defendant's cross-examination opinion just now is not completely Present the facts. The so-called Tang Qing’s edition and Mo Huayuan’s edition mentioned just now have relatively large anthology omissions. There are a total of 83 articles in the plaintiff Xiachuan’s proofreading manuscript. Tang Qing’s edition only included 17 articles, and Mo Huayuan’s edition included only 19 articles. Included [-] articles."

"Among them, in Tang Qing's edition and Mo Huayuan's edition, there are 15 duplicates. That is to say, the total number of anthologies included in the two original editions is 21. It accounts for less than 25%. Even if we take a step back and assume , the plaintiff Xiachuan’s proofreading was directly extracted from the sentence readings of the above two original books, and still more than 75% of the proofreading content was completed by him alone, and the originality of his proofreading results is unquestionable.”

"But in fact, there are a lot of mistakes in the sentence readings of Tang Qing's version and Mo Huayuan's version. In the latest version of my client Xiachuan's proofreading, there is a special postscript about the sentence reading of Tang Qing's version and Mo Huayuan's version. After textual research in Shimogawa, there were very few Orientals who were proficient in Chinese characters in the Kyushu engraving workshop 800 years ago. It was only because of the pressure to dedicate this book to the local daimyo that the engraving craftsmen still forcibly read many Chinese characters. Add many sentences to read."

"Judging from the results, the sentence readings of Tang Qing's version and Mo Huayuan's version are not only unreliable, but also cause more misleading to the proofreaders. It is worth mentioning that not only "Eastern Parade and Send Tang Ji", all There are many errors and omissions in other ancient books of Jiuzhou engraving workshop. Scholars who are engaged in the verification of ancient books all regard the sentence reading of Jiuzhou engraving workshop as non-existent."

"Therefore, the defendant's cross-examination opinion cannot be established. The fact that Tang Qing's and Mo Huayuan's manuscripts have sentence readings is not enough to overturn the originality of Xiachuan's comparative draft!"

The young plaintiffs attorney burst out with great energy again.

A counterattack once again tore up Utsunomiya's cross-examination opinions.

Judge Takanashi looked at Beiyuan at the judge's seat, "Plaintiff's attorney. Do you have any other evidence to prove?"

"Chief referee, the plaintiff has finished presenting evidence, and there is no other evidence to submit to the court." Beiyuan bowed slightly, then turned around to look at the dock, and raised his voice:

"In summary, the second to seventh sets of evidence submitted by the plaintiff jointly prove that there are six types of plagiarism in Fujimura and Shimogawa's proofreading manuscripts: style plagiarism, copy plagiarism, collation plagiarism, annotation plagiarism, paragraph plagiarism, and punctuation plagiarism. According to this, it should be determined that the works of the defendant and the plaintiff are substantially similar, and an infringement has been established!"

The long testimonial has finally come to an end.

In the lengthy comparison report, it was revealed that there were six kinds of plagiarism in Fujimura.

This is an encirclement attack from all directions.

Utsunomiya sat in the dock, his face clouded with clouds.The fact that the proof stage of this lawsuit was completed like this is indeed a bit unexpected.But to a certain extent, there is no way. If Fujimura hadn't concealed Shimokawa's third draft, at least the preparation time could be more sufficient.

However, the real outcome of this lawsuit does not lie in the court investigation...

Utsunomiya raised his head and stared at the figures of the two plaintiffs' lawyers in the opposite plaintiff's seat.

"Does the defendant's attorney have any opinions on cross-examination?" Judge Takanashi turned his head and looked at his monk mentor in the evening.

"There is nothing to add." Utsunomiya responded coldly.

Judge Takanashi looked at the clock on the wall, it was almost 2 o'clock again.In the second court hearing, more than 10 comparison reports and thousands of pages of materials were presented in court.It must be called a tug of war.

Judge Takanashi immediately announced: "Now the court investigation phase is officially over. The plaintiff has presented the corresponding evidence on its claim, and the defendant has issued a cross-examination opinion on the evidence presented. The court will continue at the same time and place next week. Then the next The trial of the case will enter the stage of court debate. The court will issue another subpoena to notify the representatives of all parties.”

"The court is now adjourned."

"Crack!"

The crisp sound of the gavel sounded.

The second trial is officially over.

Miyakawa let out a long breath on the plaintiff's table, stretched his two beautiful crescent eyebrows, turned his head to look at the man beside him, and said with a happy smile, "Beiyuan, you have worked hard. Judging from the court investigation, you are Pressed the head of the famous professor on the opposite side."

Although the trial was over, Beiyuan's expression did not relax. He turned his face and said, "The real battle has not yet begun. Next, Miyagawa, you have to continue to help. Take everything you learned during college The knowledge of copyright law can be used.”

Miyagawa was stunned for a moment, she didn't expect Beiyuan to still have such a serious expression after the court session.She was suddenly puzzled.I don't understand why the man in front of me still looks like he is facing a big enemy and is on high alert even though he has gained the upper hand in the court investigation.

Miyagawa couldn't help feeling tense.Because she knew that since Beiyuan said so, it must be in the next court trial, and she would encounter unprecedented difficulties and challenges.

At this moment, Imanishi is also sitting in the public gallery, crossing his legs, listening to this morning's trial leisurely.He narrowed his eyes slightly, looking at the figure sitting next to his daughter.

Judging from the court hearing in the morning, if an outsider was watching, he would definitely feel that Beiyuan had already gained the upper hand, throwing comparison reports one after another in the other party's face, and even forced the defendant's attorney twice Unable to respond.Add to that the dazzling contrast effect projected by the projector, and the so-called "six types" of plagiarism.All of this will give people an illusion, as if the plaintiff's lawyer has won the initiative.

However, under this superficial advantage, there are actually dangers everywhere.

Imanishi has also represented intellectual property cases, and he has also dabbled in intellectual property laws.Indeed, from Beiyuan who just graduated and has no practical experience in copyright cases, it is already very good to be able to achieve this level.

However, if you look at it from an insider's point of view——

Beiyuan is about to lose.

(End of this chapter)