Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 331 Questions
Hearing Utsunomiya's sharp rebuttal, the university management in the auditorium was greatly relieved, and their faces were filled with admiration.At the moment when Beiyuan finished commenting on plagiarism, many managers even felt "it's over".However, Utsunomiya stood up again, dismantled the opponent's offensive, and turned around again in an instant.

The famous law professor looked at Beiyuan coldly, as if he thought the attack just now was not strong enough, and wanted to fire again.

Utsunomiya decided to let the young man in front of him experience the horror of being completely buried in court.Immediately, he picked up two copies of Tang Ji again, flipped through one of the pages, and said:

"Even if the annotations of ancient texts are not directly quoted, we can also see a large number of examples, which do not constitute so-called plagiarism. For example, the third chapter of Chapter 2 of Sending Tang Ji tells the story of Guan Gu's acquaintance with a local man in the Shu area. A superior officer named Cao Jie. Among them, in the notes, although Fujimura wrote that "Cao Jie is a person with a bright personality, he is eager for public service and righteous." However, this sentence actually comes from the description of Cao Jie's character in the Tang Book, "Cao Jie Generous in nature, emphasizing meaning.’ Under such circumstances, although the sentence is a modern text, it does not constitute the so-called similarity in fact.”

"For another example, the fifth chapter of Chapter 3 of Sending Tang Ji records that Guan Gu came to Cangcheng in Qinchuan. Among them, Fujimura made an annotation, stating that the predecessor of Cangcheng was actually Lecheng built by Kong Ming of the Three Kingdoms. Among them, the sentence actually The above also comes from the description in the ancient book "Qinguan City Records" that "Cangcheng, the building of Zhuge in the Han Dynasty, was originally named Le". Therefore, although Fujimura has made modern annotations here, its content actually comes from Ancient books are not the same."

Utsunomiya attacked fiercely one after another, as if he wanted to tear up all the evidence that the young man just gave before he gave up.

The university management members in the auditorium also showed subtle knowing smiles, as if in the arena of ancient Rome, admiring how the gladiators on the opposite side were bitten bit by bit by the ferocious beasts, and their lives ended.

Looking at Kitahara's figure, Utsunomiya continued to speak loudly, "Moreover, there are many annotations in Shimokawa's proofreading manuscript that are purely factual descriptions. For example, in the third chapter of Chapter 4, Guan Gu and Jiannan Road Festival Among them, Xiachuan’s notes here are only a rough record of the birth and death years of the Jiedushi, and a brief quotation from Tang Shu’s evaluation. Here, the introduction of Jiannan Road’s Jiedushi is also It is an extremely simple presentation of facts, without any original expression contained in it."

The famous professor of law flipped through the records of sending Tang Dynasty page by page, "Chief referee! After consulting, we can find that the so-called annotations in the plaintiff Xiachuan's draft are actually mainly composed of two parts."

"The first part is nothing more than citing the corresponding historical documents. The second part is a simple narrative of historical facts. Neither part contains any original expression factors. In this case, the so-called similarity is simply It cannot be avoided."

Utsunomiya took a step forward, "For example, the record of the birth and death of the Jiannan Road Jiedushi mentioned just now. This kind of record is repeated. What's the problem? Does my client Fujimura have to make up a different one? Years of birth and death, to avoid the so-called similarities? The same historical fact, can Shimokawa write it, but Fujimura can’t write it?!"

"Therefore, chief judge! The so-called comparison report shown by the plaintiff's attorney cannot be used to prove the so-called plagiarism of the annotations. The contents of the annotations are either materials in the public domain, or are extremely simple factual statements. It cannot prove the existence of the so-called plagiarism fact!"

Utsunomiya's voice fell heavily.

This is a textbook-like cross-examination opinion.

A complete demonstration of how to give the opponent the most ferocious refutation from beginning to end.

This famous professor of law not only showed that annotations purely citing ancient texts should be excluded, but also showed that even annotations written in modern languages ​​do not necessarily constitute the so-called similarity.

These arguments one after another, poured on the opponent's position like a barrage of artillery barrages all over the sky.Even the representatives of the student union who sympathized with Xiachuan in the auditorium were stunned, and were vaguely moved by the cross-examination opinions.As for the university management, quite a few people directly showed complacent expressions, ready to appreciate the defeat of the plaintiff's lawyer on the opposite side.

Miyagawa also heard his heart beating from the side.In the intellectual property law confrontation between Utsunomiya and Kitahara, he was completely out of control, and could only... just sit on his seat.

All eyes in the courtroom were on the side of the plaintiff's seat.

It seems that the plaintiff's seat at this moment has become ruins under the flames of war.

Those gazes seem to no longer believe that there are still surviving figures in such ruins.

Many famous people in the legal field who came from other places also breathed a sigh of relief.They breathed a sigh of relief because this kind of scene is normal.It is normal for a young lawyer who has just graduated to be silenced by a famous professor of intellectual property law in court.However, the previous fierce confrontation between the two sides, which was evenly matched and each had its own merits, was truly extremely abnormal.

"Does the plaintiff's attorney need to respond?" Judge Takanashi asked softly in the referee's seat.

After asking this question, the young male lawyer sitting in the plaintiff's seat smiled lightly.

Yes, in the face of such a dangerous situation, he still smiled.

It was as if Utsunomiya's serial attack just now had never existed before.

He raised his head slowly, and his lazy eyes fell on the opposite dock, as if to announce—what you did just now was useless.

The moment Utsunomiya saw Kitahara's smile, he was stunned.He didn't know why the young man could still laugh under such circumstances, and it was so natural and comfortable.It seemed that he was not the one who was pressed for questioning just now.Do not!It should even be said that it seemed as if he was questioning someone just now.

Beiyuan held Tang Ji in his hand, stood up, and turned to one of the pages, "The second chapter of Tang Ji Chapter 3, here is a note, so strange. The second chapter tells about Guan Gu's experience passing through Tongguan. Among them , In the annotation, here is the citation of the ancient book "Tongguan Kaolue" that "there are two sluice gates in the north and south, seven in the south and nine in the north, and the regulations are grand and cool, reflecting the Sichuan plateau."

"Please note that there is a typo here. There are two sluices at the North and South Shuiguan, and they are written as two works of sluices. May I ask why there is this typo in Xiachuan's proofreading, and this typo also appears in the proofreading of the defendant Fujimura?"

Like a child, asking curious questions.

Beiyuan's question floated in the courtroom.

(End of this chapter)