Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 204 The Third Person

After Beiyuan finished speaking, Machiko was already in a daze.The sound of the clerk typing on the keyboard echoed in the courtroom. The keyboard that was pressed continuously recorded all the words of Machiko and Beiyuan in the court transcript verbatim.Machiko wanted to speak again, but the cold text on the screen could no longer be changed.

In order to refute the male lawyer, she said less than two hundred words.

However, just these two hundred words directly made Qingyetai Apartment bear the liability for compensation for the excessive seizure of Gaojing's land.

Machiko has been in court with Gu Meimen many times, and she is already very familiar with the court.However, at this moment, she felt that the court in front of her had become strange, like a monster with its bloody mouth wide open. As long as she was not careful, she would be swallowed by this monster.

Machiko looked at the male lawyer in front of her again, and couldn't help feeling a creepy feeling in her heart.

At this moment, Sheng Shan, director of the owner's committee of Aobadai Apartment, was sitting in the auditorium. Hearing the words of the male lawyer on the other side, his mouth was slightly opened, and he was suddenly dumbfounded.This... This is different from what lawyer Dai said back then.A few days ago, when he was persuading Aobatai Apartment to join the lawsuit as a third party, Attorney Dai did not mention that the apartment might be liable for joining the lawsuit.

However, now, the Beiyuan lawyer said that the apartment had prevented Gao Jing from exercising his right to sue, and he was liable for compensation for the excess land seizure.

A drop of sweat rolled down Katsuyama's face.That day, it was I who proposed to hold a business committee meeting on the spot and entrusted lawyer Dai to join the lawsuit.I was also the one who encouraged the committee members to vote for it.

If, in the end, the apartment had to bear additional responsibilities because of joining this lawsuit, then wouldn't he be a sinner in the apartment, wouldn't he want to offend many powerful people in the apartment.

Katsuyama's face gradually became ugly.

Judge Jiang Tian, ​​who was sitting on the trial bench, looked at Machiko and said, "I have understood the claims of both parties. Please, my agent, continue to speak on the second and third person, Baileziwei Catering Club."

Machiko's hands were already trembling slightly, but she still forcibly calmed down, took the document given by Gu Meimen, and read: "Bai Le Zi Wei Catering Club is a company that operates catering and hotels, and its legal representative is Yumi Mitani. .Five years ago, Baile Taste Catering Club and Chimu Hotel Group reached a "Hotel Contract Management Agreement" regarding the operation of the General Hotel. The agreement specifies the hotel's building structure, building leasing matters, and corresponding contracting fees .The contract period is 15 years.”

"The General Hotel involved in the case is a landmark tourist building recognized by the Shinjuku District Bureau of Culture and Tourism in Tokyo, and can enjoy the right to place advertisements on public websites, bulletin boards, etc. in the city hall. Therefore, the relevant operating lease of the General Hotel needs to be reported to the city hall Announcement on the website. After Baile Taste Catering Club and Chimu Hotel Group reached the "Hotel Contracting and Operation Agreement", the relevant operating lease profile has been announced on the city hall website."

"It doesn't matter whether the building of General Hotel in this case encroached on the land of the plaintiff Gaojing. Assuming that even if the hotel did occupy the land, then Chimu Hotel Group has no right to lease Gaojing's land. However, not having the right to lease does not hinder the lease The validity of the contract. The operating lease status of Baile Taste Catering Club and Chimu Hotel Group has been announced on the relevant website."

"Now the plaintiff, Gao Jing, requests to demolish the building that the hotel has encroached on the land. But the building is actually a load-bearing column of the hotel. Once it is removed, the entire hotel building will also be demolished, and the third party, Baileweiwei Catering Club, will also be forced to withdraw from the lease site."

"The plaintiff Gao Jing, as the person involved in the encroachment of the land, has not made any statement on the land occupation for many years. And after the general hotel's operating leasing matters were publicized, he did not raise any objections. In this regard, it should be considered that the plaintiff Gao Jing has already expressed his opinion on Baile Taste. The operating lease relationship between the Catering Club and Chimu Hotel Group has been acquiesced. Therefore, the operating lease relationship between Park Le Taste Catering Club and Chimu Hotel Group has to be sued against Gao Jing. Gao Jing should wait for the end of the hotel lease relationship before filing a lawsuit to eliminate the nuisance .”

After the beautiful lawyer's voice fell, another third person blocked the way and prevented the opposite lawyer from exercising his rights to Chimu Hotel Group.According to Machiko, Takai must wait another ten years until the lease relationship ends before asking the hotel to demolish the building.At this moment, no one in the auditorium thought that claiming rights from the hotel would go through such a difficult process.

Don't just step past the Aobadai apartment.

But also to step past the operator of the actual lease.

This is the horror of barrister Gu Meimen.

Now, the plaintiff's lawyers have to cross these two thresholds before they actually face the defendant Chimu Hotel Group.

Machiko thought it was just luck that Kitahara could refute on the spot.None of her court documents concerning the third party were submitted to the other party in advance.Therefore, the other party can only answer by relying on the on-the-spot reaction.The reason why Beiyuan was able to react was probably just a coincidence, maybe he had handled a similar case before.

However, people can quickly react once, but it is impossible to react the second time.

In particular, facing this move, it was all a killer move carefully concocted by Gu Meimen.

It is impossible for a young lawyer who is about his own age to react.

Machiko put down the document in her hand, looked up again, and saw the appearance of the male lawyer, her extraordinarily beautiful face froze again.

He...he was still laughing.

For... why? !

Beiyuan shook the suit jacket on his body, and he had a sense of chicness based on his east-west, north-south wind. He smiled slightly and said: "According to the judicial interpretation of the Supreme Court on hearing disputes over urban housing lease contracts. The leasing contract of the planning permit should be invalid. The pillars of the General Hotel crossed the land boundary, indicating that the construction of the hotel involved in the case did not proceed within the scope of the permit. The part beyond the land boundary should be regarded as an illegal building without a permit thing."

"The operation contracting agreement reached between Baile Taste Catering Co., Ltd. and Chimu Hotel Group includes the terms of leasing the hotel buildings to Baile Taste Catering Co., Ltd. Now that the buildings beyond the boundary have not obtained a permit, the relevant lease The contract should also be deemed invalid in accordance with the relevant provisions of the Supreme Court."

"An invalid legal act has no effect from the beginning. Therefore, what the other party's agent said, the plaintiff Gao Jing acquiesced in the operating lease relationship of Baileziwei Catering Club, etc., has no legal basis. On the contrary, the leased land relationship involved in the case is invalid, and Gao Jing cannot be sued A lawsuit for the exclusion of nuisances!"

(End of this chapter)