Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 171 Entwined with each other (more will be added tomorrow!)

Seeing Miyagawa's rebuttal again, Machiko was a little surprised.After all... After all, the other party only had less than a week to prepare, and they were able to do this to this extent.Machiko can't imagine what kind of work intensity the other party has been in these few days.

Miyagawa stood up again, looked at Judge Jiang Tian and said, "Chief referee, even if you take a step back and say that there is only one 'must pass' for the course in this case, the law also stipulates the corresponding exemption. That is, if the road is blocked by the neighbor If the claimant for the right of way creates it himself, then he is not eligible to request the right of way for neighboring lands.”

"For example, suppose the owner of a piece of land voluntarily blocks its access to the outside world. Then the owner of this piece of land cannot request access to the owner of the adjacent land."

"In this regard, the defendant's attorney will submit a set of evidence to prove that the isolation of the Aobadai road also plays a role in promoting it."

Miyagawa took out an old newspaper from the file bag on the desktop and displayed it in front of everyone.

But I saw that the newspaper was old and yellowed, with a black and white photo printed on it.The photo shows a slope of green grass, which is the same slope where Aoba Terrace Apartment was adjacent to General Hotel.From the photos, it can be seen that the underground garage of General Hotel had not been expanded at that time, and the downlink lane had not yet appeared in the photos.

But next to this black and white photo, there is a huge title printed, "The luxury house is built on a high slope, what to do if it collapses in rainy days?"

"Chief referee, this is a report about the Aoba Terrace apartment seven years ago." Miyagawa said in a deep voice, "There are three buildings in the Aoba Terrace apartment. The one adjacent to the General Hotel is the latest It was built at that time. At that time, when the third apartment building was being built, there was a dispute among the owners of Aobadai Apartment about how to use the border between the third apartment building and the General Hotel.”

"At that time, the internal owners were divided into two factions. The first faction believed that the adjacent land should be opened up with the Jiangjun Hotel, so that apartment owners could walk to the hotel clubhouse for consumption. A mini garden. The owners of the two factions debated endlessly, and then held a meeting of owners to vote, and finally the second plan was passed."

“At the beginning, the construction of the earth slope caused controversy in public opinion. That is, some editorials believed that after the completion of the earth slope, due to the soft soil, small landslides may occur, and condemned the construction of the earth slope.”

At this time, a copy of this newspaper has also been passed to the trial seat and the opposite dock.

Holding the somewhat yellowed newspaper in his hand, Miyagawa raised his voice and said, "Chief referee. The green grass slope on the boundary between Aobadai Apartment and the General Hotel was built by him, which ultimately made it impossible for the apartment to use its connection with the General Hotel." Access to the adjacent land of the Grand Hotel. According to the law, if the landowner’s own actions lead to the isolation of the road, it is not allowed to request access to the adjacent area. Accordingly, Aobadai Apartment should bear the responsibility of the road isolation and impassability. as a result of."

Just as Machiko's contract paper from more than 30 years ago came out, facing the old newspaper that suddenly appeared in front of him, Machiko was also a little dazed, with her mouth slightly opened.She kept scanning the copy of the newspaper on the desktop, carefully reading every word on it.

After reading, her hands were already trembling slightly.

Machiko she miscalculated.

Unexpectedly, the grassy slope with the Jiangjun Hotel turned out to be of this origin!
Seeing that Miyagawa had collected information to such an extent, Beiyuan couldn't help being slightly surprised.After all, it was only a few short days, and it was really remarkable that Miyagawa was able to do this.

Beiyuan was a little curious about this old newspaper, and after Miyagawa returned to the dock, he picked up the newspaper and read it, his eyes swept to the end of the article.

But I saw that the author of this article is:

【Training reporter Niwa Marina】

Seeing this familiar name, the female reporter in the Kawamoto Expressway case, the corners of Bei Yuan's mouth twitched slightly.This... This world is really small.

Also...it's no wonder that Miyagawa was able to find this information. It is estimated that in the past few days...he should have invited...a lot of foreign aid.

Miyagawa turned around and saw Kitahara looking at the newspaper, and raised the corners of his mouth triumphantly, as if to say come and praise me.However, thinking that Beiyuan was still facing the bank's debt collection, this expression seemed inappropriate, so Miyagawa restrained his smile again with a "whoosh".

At this time, Machiko felt a little bit overwhelmed on the opposite side.She had never felt that this battle was such a difficult one.Think about when I reported at the Grand General Hotel before, I also said that the other party was a lawyer assigned by Legal Aid, and the level may be below the average.Thinking about it now, I really didn't know where my confidence was at the time to make such an assertion.

And this is only the opponent's first line of defense.

Even if you admit that you have the right of way in neighboring land, you will still face the problems of the scope of opening and the amount of compensation.

Machiko's brain was running fast, carefully chewing every word that Miyagawa said just now, after a lot of hard thinking, as if he had discovered something in an instant, he stood up again and said: "Objection! Chief referee. This situation does not apply to the terms of the adjacent right of way."

"The reason why the green grass slope cannot be built to meet the national standard is caused by the downlink lane leading to the garage built by the General Hotel later. Therefore, it is not caused by the unilateral padding of the unearthed slope of the Aoba Terrace Apartment. The law clearly stipulates that only When the landowner’s own actions lead to the road isolation, the right to request the right of way in the adjacent land is denied. There is no provision in the law when the road isolation is caused by the land owner and a third party at the same time. According to This should be considered as the law does not deny the right to claim passage to neighboring lands under such circumstances."

Machiko almost held her breath and finished this discussion.

After the words fell, even she felt a little admiration for her on-the-spot reaction ability.

The lawyer Miyagawa in front of him actually forcefully forced out his potential.

At this time, between Machiko and Miyagawa, it seemed that the two sides had been fighting for a whole day and night. This small court seemed to have become a battlefield, with corpses lying everywhere and the smell of blood, both sides wielding weapons. We all feel exhausted.

At this moment, Judge Jiang Tian was sitting on the trial bench, with a very calm expression on his face, which made it difficult to figure out which side of his opinion he was leaning towards in his heart.

This kind of elusiveness, on the contrary, exacerbated the tension of these two female lawyers.

After the bloody confrontation, Machiko and Miyagawa still need to endure the mental torture from the judge's uncertainty.

Will Judge Eda support Aobadai Apartment's request for the right of way in the neighboring land?

(PS: more will be added tomorrow)
(End of this chapter)